Great Music
W. Gawlas | 01/03/2004
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I bought this CD and gave it as a Christmas gift. It was so well recieved that I bought another one for myself. Great Jazz standards sung beautifully. Amanda's original songs are also beautiful. Thank you so much!"
AD HOMINEM CRITIQUES ARE BESIDE THE POINT...
W. Gawlas | pittsburgh | 08/19/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I *DO* feel sorry for the carefully-unidentified first reviewer...who
was clearly offended by Ms. Carr's snottiness (and whether it was justified by his initial contact we shall never know). But THAT was a
personal affront. It must have colored his/her reaction to the singer's
CD... resulting in a "review" which was definitely not "on point."
If anyone out there in "Listener Land" remembers the magnificent Irene
Kral, they will be glad for the talents of Amanda Carr--no matter how she
may condescend to hopeful correspondents. We need to keep separate our
personal quarrels from our opinions about up-and-coming jazz singers.
They DO need all of the positive reinforcement we can give them.
And Amanda Carr deserves much better than mean, revenge-laden AD HOMINEM
attacks. It is patently unfair to use a semi-public forum like the
Amazon Review Section to "get even" with a person that you feel has
"dumped" on you. In THIS forum, the MUSIC is *ALL* that matters."