"Schiff has extraordinary sensitivity to the wonderful nuances of the primary theme. The variations are each fresh, necessary, logical, and exciting. I can't imagine them any other way after hearing this definitive performance. I have listened to many other performers attempt the Goldberg variations, and this is the best by far. (Gould, just to name one, is too ponderous and overwrought. Not to mention his annoying humming and tuneless singing.) Even if you already own a version, treat yourself to this one."
Breathtaking
R. Albin | 11/06/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"One of the most breathtakingly beautiful performances of anything I've ever heard. I later heard other performances i.e. by Gould, that left me cold. Schiff's performance is elegant perfection, supremely musical and intellectually powerful. Highly recommended."
Gorgeous but Romantic
R. Albin | Ann Arbor, Michigan United States | 10/05/2003
(4 out of 5 stars)
"This is a truly lovely recording of one of Bach's greatest compositions. Schiff's playing is superb. Why only 4 stars? As commented by other reviewers, this is something of a Romantic version of Bach. This is certainly a legitimate approach and I have to say that I listen to this recording over and over again. Still, if one were going to buy one recording of the Goldberg Variations, I'd recommend buying a more Baroque interpretation. If you want two or more recordings, I recommend this one strongly."
Carnegie Hall etc
R. Albin | 03/06/2002
(3 out of 5 stars)
"I went to the Carnegie Hall Goldberg and Well Tempered Klavier in 2000/2001 (As well as the Lincoln Center Partitas) and agree that Schiff has grown past this interpretation and it would be womderful to get a new recording by him (although this will probably become interesting for comparison purposes). As for the pro who says get the older Gould version if you don't like the humming, I'd like to point out that the 1955 version is played about twice as fast as the 1982 one. These recordings illustrate the beginning and the end of Gould's career and could not be more different from one another - the 1982 being the definitive one.
As for the liberties one should or should not take with the score I believe that is debatable - does anyone really know today how Bach wanted these played?"
Unsure about Penguin....
R. Albin | 08/06/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I'm rather unsure about Penguin's chosen version of Schiff's playing of this wonderful piece by J.S. Bach. Despite Schiff being an amazing performer, I feel he probably needs to mature with the piece. I went to listen to Schiff perform these Variations in Carnegie Hall not too long ago, and it was most breathtaking and spectacular. Schiff is definitely not a performer to be missed; however, Penguin's version of Schiff's playing isn't quite the best around."