Search - Johann Sebastian Bach, Martin Pearlman, Boston Baroque :: Bach - Mass in b minor / Heaston · Hanslowe · Rabiner · M. Tucker · N. Berg · Boston Baroque · Pearlman

Johann Sebastian Bach, Martin Pearlman, Boston Baroque
Bach - Mass in b minor / Heaston · Hanslowe · Rabiner · M. Tucker · N. Berg · Boston Baroque · Pearlman
Genre: Classical

Track Listings (12) - Disc #1
1. Kyrie Eleison
2. Christe Eleison
3. Kyrie Eleison
4. Gloria In Excesis Deo
5. Et In Terra Pax
6. Laudamus Te
7. Gratias Agimus Tibi
8. Domine Deus
9. Qui Tollis Peccata Mundi
10. Qui Sedes Ad Dextram Patris
11. Quoniam Tu Solus Sanctus
12. Cum Sancto Spiritu
Track Listings (15) - Disc #2
1. Credo In Unum Deum
2. Patrem Omnipotentem
3. Et In Unum Dominum
4. Et Incarnatus Est
5. Crucifixus
6. Et Resurrexit
7. Et In Spiritum Sanctum
8. Confiteor
9. Et Exspecto
10. Sanctus
11. Osanna In Excelsis
12. Benedictus
13. Osanna In Excelsis
14. Agnus Dei
15. Dona Nobis Pacem

Larger Image

CD Details

All Artists: Johann Sebastian Bach, Martin Pearlman, Boston Baroque, Nicole Heaston, Theodora Hanslowe, Ellen Rabiner, Mark Tucker, Nathan Berg
Title: Bach - Mass in b minor / Heaston · Hanslowe · Rabiner · M. Tucker · N. Berg · Boston Baroque · Pearlman
Members Wishing: 0
Total Copies: 0
Label: Telarc
Release Date: 2/22/2000
Genre: Classical
Styles: Opera & Classical Vocal, Historical Periods, Baroque (c.1600-1750)
Number of Discs: 2
SwapaCD Credits: 2
UPC: 089408051722

Synopsis

Amazon.com

Right out of the box, this must be considered one of the finer accounts of the B minor Mass currently available on disc, and at Telarc's two-for-one pricing, it's one of the most affordable as well. Recorded in May 1999 at Mechanics Hall in Worcester, Massachusetts, it features a well-nigh ideal complement of musicians--a chorus of 28 and an orchestra of 31--in an acoustically excellent setting, under the direction of one of America's foremost baroque specialists, Martin Pearlman. Fluent, engaging, informed, and insightful, the performance is proof that North American period-instrument playing has come of age. In fact, the playing of the Boston Baroque ensemble is the chief glory of this account. Individually and collectively an outstanding group of instrumentalists, they deliver the obbligato solos with impeccable flair across the board, while their tutti playing is agile yet substantial in sound. The Boston Baroque choristers are not quite up to the level of their colleagues; in places, their singing lacks the ultimate degree of polish and projection, though it is unfailingly animated and communicative: witness the beautiful job they do with "Et expecto resurrectionem mortuorum" and the final "Dona nobis pacem." There is much good work from the soloists as well, though a couple of them phrase their numbers rather choppily and could show more expressive finesse. Telarc's recording is spacious and atmospheric, yet dry enough to be nicely detailed. There are also good notes from conductor Pearlman, who with this release further solidifies his reputation as an interpreter of Bach. --Ted Libbey

Similar CDs

	Tito Rodriguez Estoy Como Nunca Genres: International Music, Jazz, Latin Music Label: Polygram Records
?

	Jose Feliciano Boleros Para Siempre (Dig) Genres: Pop, Rock, Latin Music Label: Sony U.S. Latin
?

	Gina Villalobos Days on Their Side Genres: Alternative Rock, Pop, Rock Label: Face West Records
?

Similarly Requested CDs

	Gordon Jones, John Potter Officium - Jan Gabarek & The Hilliard Ensemble Genres: Jazz, Special Interest, Pop, Classical Label: ECM Records
1

	George Frederick Handel, Jane Glover, Neville Marriner Händel: Water Music Genre: Classical Label: Philips
?

	Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Claudio Abbado, Karita Mattila Mozart - Requiem / Mattila, Mingardo, Schade, Terfel, Berlin Phil., Abbado Genre: Classical Label: Deutsche Grammophon
1

	Andrew Lloyd Webber Magic of Andrew Lloyd Webber Genres: Pop, Soundtracks, Classical, Broadway & Vocalists Label: Madacy Records
3

	Chopin, Brailowsky Polonaises / Fantasie Impromptu Genres: Dance & Electronic, Classical Label: Sony
1

	Loreena McKennitt The Book of Secrets Genres: Folk, International Music, New Age, Pop, Rock Label: Quinlan Road
36

	Georg Philipp Telemann, Helmut Winschermann, Max Pommer Telemann: Trumpet Concerto; Trumpet Suite; Overture Genres: Special Interest, Classical Label: Delta
1

	James Galway Wind Beneath My Wings Genres: International Music, New Age, Pop, Classical Label: RCA
3

	George Winston Autumn Genres: Jazz, New Age, Pop Label: Windham Hill Records
5

	Franz Xaver Gruber, John Ireland, David Overton James Galway's Christmas Carol Genres: International Music, Special Interest, New Age, Pop, Classical Label: RCA
4

CD Reviews

REMEMBER PEOPLE, THIS IS A MASS, NOT A REQUIEM!

Trevor Gillespie | 03/16/2000

(5 out of 5 stars)

"It seems that popular opinion has decreed for the B minor mass to be played with utmost gravity and weight. It should ALWAYS sound "German." It should ALWAYS sound "Baroque" in the literary sense. The drama and the agony must be placed-- ALWAYS--in the foreground. Personally, I think this performance practice should not ALWAYS apply to masterworks like the Bach's B minor mass. Many of those so-called definitive versions (Jochum, Shaw, Karajan, etc.) have wearied me so to the point of distraction with their hyperintensive seriousnesses and slow, teutonic pull. This is a new age, by crackey: I believe "church music" should be presented more directly and more humanely, sporting a less arch-romantic point of view. (And let's remember, people, the Bach's B-minor mass is first and foremost a MASS, not a REQUIEM. A powerfully involved, nonliturgical mass, perhaps, but still a MASS in it's practical construction and use!)Once or twice, I've heard this work proclaimed as the "holy of holies" of Lutheran choral composition. I might give in to that concession, for perhaps it is. But couldn't someone come along and simply lighten up the textures a bit, push the tempos just a tad, and subdue the dramatic voguing associated with traditional practice? Couldn't the conductor and the ensemble allow the words, music, and structural designs of the KYRIE, the CRUCIFIXUS, the ET RESERREXIT, and the SANCTUS speak for themselves? (I think, Rifkin may have attempted a "clearer" version during the 70s, by placing one voice, instrumental or otherwise, to a part!)But at last and finally, Maestro Martin Perlman and his wonderful Boston Baroque have heard and answered my prayers for a more direct--dare I say it? almost AMERICAN-- interpretation. And I return to my CD player with fresh, interested ears. The notes themselves now seem to witness directly of God's prevenient grace unaffected by the private dramaturgy of conductors of an earlier age.Thank you, Boston Baroque. And for those of you (trads) who cry "Blasphemy, Blasphemy" to Messr Perlman's performance choices, I only have to say to you: Bad putty tat. Bad. You should be ashamed."

Outstanding Performance of this Great Work

Thomas H. Moody | Nobleboro, ME United States | 03/13/2000

(5 out of 5 stars)

"I have been secretly hoping that Boston Baroque would record the Bach B Minor Mass for some time now. I knew that they could present this great work in a clear, precise and emotional way. I have not been disappointed. Anyone familiar with previous recordings of Martin Pearlman and Boston Baroque (i.e. Handel's Messiah, Monteverdi's Vespers) knows what Pearlman and his group are capable of. Once again they deliver. I have heard (and own) almost all of the early music performances of this gigantic work and have found true satisfaction here, where most of the others always had some weakness along the way(with the exception of the Gardiner recording). Don't hesitate to leap at this recording. Onward Boston Baroque and I hope that there is a recording of some Handel oratorio in the near future. Having heard this group live many times, I know that they have a great repertoire under their belts which is just waiting to be committed to CD. Also kudos to Telarc for pricing the two CDs for the cost of one. Making great music more affordable to the public is something more CD companies should be doing."

Bach at his best

Trevor Gillespie | San Jose, California United States | 03/15/2000

(5 out of 5 stars)

"When I think of all the things Bach accomplished in his life in music, the one aspect that continually amazes me is his ability to write choral music. The Mass in b Minor is in fact a major work. Pearlman brings all the elements together to have an end product of sheer beauty and listening enjoyment. Telarc did something outstanding on the recording of this work. This new DSD technology is superb. In this recording, there is increased clarity, brilliance, presence, and dynamics---in short a truer sound. The Boston Baroque plays excellently (if that is a real adverb). Compare this "period instrument" recording with what you may have and see for yourself----this new release is awesome."

Worthy Performance - Balance problem

Robert L. Edwards | New York, NY United States | 11/26/2009

(4 out of 5 stars)

"To be brief: overall its a good performance. Its a worthy recording and would make a fine addition to your collection now that Telarc is defunct and prices are lowered. The recorded sound has the feel of a live performance as opposed to a studio recording, but is certainly better than one might actually hear in a live setting. Pearlman pays attention to period styling and respects the composer's intentions.

On the negative side, the tenors are way too light and do not match the resonance or sonority of the other voices. Without delving into speculative reasons (some of these reviewers are so naive!), there is a recorded balance problem here. The basses are too distant and the overall clarity is muffled. Detail is lost. Its always difficult to strike a balance between proper small forces like this and hall resonance. Its a rare Telarc miss.

But all in all, this recording is worth having. There is no perfect b minor. This one ranks high.

"

One of the best interpretations available, but second to Gar

D. Jack Elliot | Omaha, Nebraska | 06/01/2007

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Gardiner's classic reading with the English Baroque Soloists is the unavoidable point of comparison for any period instrument reading of the Bach B Minor Mass, and Pearlman and the Boston Baroque measure up admirably to Gardiner's definitive account. Where Gardiner's is an exuberant, dramatic performance, Pearlman's interpretation finds instead a sense of contented calm, a spiritual inner peace. There is less edge-of-your seat euphoria, and more of a joyful, peaceful glow from within. (This is particularly true in the Kyrie and Gloria sections; Pearlman's reading is more animated and dramatic in the Credo---thus it seemed to me that for Pearlman, the Credo is the piece's center of gravity.) True enough, Gardiner's is the greater reading (indeed, it is one of history's greatest performances of any repertoire), but Pearlman's remains a performance of the first order.

For Pearlman this is more a choral piece than an orchestral piece. The voices outbalance the instruments almost two to one much of the time, where for Gardiner the balance favors the orchestra, often to the same extent. Though it's interesting to note that other reviewers here do not agree with me about this. I suppose that in a huge score such as this, as is often commented with regard to different interpretations of the Mahler symphonies, there are almost endless possible choices of textural emphasis; perhaps everyone has their favorite orchestral passages in this piece, and will find the orchestra overbalanced if those are not the orchestral passages that are emphasized. I must admit that I missed the instruments in places. I am a trumpet player myself, and was especially interested to hear the Boston Baroque's first trumpeter, Friedemann Immer, play the first trumpet parts here. Together with Crispian Steele-Perkins and Niklas Eklund, Immer is amongst the world's elite exponents of the valveless Baroque trumpet, and has recorded the best performance of the Bach 2nd Brandenburg Concerto we have. But he is generally kept well in the background here, even in extended, important solo trumpet passages, such as in Credo in unum Deum."