A commanding soloist, now in better sound
Santa Fe Listener | Santa Fe, NM USA | 11/10/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This famous recording of the Brahms Second with Richter used to be unrivaled and still stands at the top of the field. Richter possesses so much power and authority, yet can be so restrained and mysterious when he wants, that no one quite challenges him. In memory he barnstormed more than he actually does here; Pollini and Barenboim are almost as virtuosic. Even after forty years, however, there are moments when no one can phrase like him--Richter seems to think in paragraphs, not single passages--and he remains the only pianist who makes you believe this incredibly challenging work is easy to play. (At 44 min. this is also one of the fastest Brahms Seconds on CD.)
The weakness of this recording is two-fold. The recorded sound is a bit brittle and thin (now coniserably improved in RCA's current remastering). Richter isn't given the gorgeous sonority one hears from Pollini on DG with Abbado (particulary their 1995 remake in digital sound). And Leinsdorf, if better than his usual literal self, at times seems to impede what Richter wants to do. They open the first movement in different worlds, but after that, Leinsdorf manages to gather enough momentum to keep up with his soloist. One wonders how unleashed Richter would have been if the shceduled conductor (I think it was Reiner) hadn't bowed out.
Those two drawbacks aside, this superb CD will never go out of print. As you listen to Richter so totally dominate the closing pages, you feel glad about that--every future improvement in sound will make the performance more alive. The coupling is his equally acclaimed performance of Brahms's youthful First Sonata, in all its rambling glory. The pianist was much older, in his early seventies, when this live account from 1988 was captured. The piano sound is a bit too clangy and brittle, but in this repertoire Richter was competing only with himself."
This is the one to own
Sebastian Winston | San Diego, CA | 03/13/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I was shocked when I first heard this performance of the Brahms Bb major. I had been buying recordings of the piece like they were going out of style but when I heard Richter/Leinsdorf/CSO, it was like I was finally hearing the piece the way that I heard it inside my head. For starters, Richter is ridiculous. His chops are way above anything I have every heard from anyone else and his sound puts his vaunted colleague Gilels to shame. Leinsdorf brings an incredible sheen to the orchestra and balance that delivers a nearly perfect performance. And, of course, the CSO just can't be outplayed PERIOD. THIS is the one to own.
"
Richter masters Brahms
Christopher Kosloske | 11/05/2008
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Brahms' 2nd Piano Concerto in B-Flat, Op. 83 is one of the more popular concertos played in the classical music world. Sviatoslav Richter and this performance should immediately comes to mind when considering this masterful concerto. Although Gilels is known to have said "Wait till you hear Richter", I believe Gilels interpretation of the this concerto with Eugen Jochum is the definitive recording of the work. The performance awarded a Grammy, Richter was not particularly thrilled with the performance. The cd also features a much less popular work in that of the first Brahms Sonata. This extremely underrated Sonata is amazingly played by Richter, and ranks among the best performances, along with those who specialized in Brahms such as Julius Katchen."