'Please Sir, can I have more?' - Oliver Twist
Mireille Wastwater | England | 10/17/2001
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I heard Hough perform the F minor Sonata at the RFH in London this year and it was broadcast later on radio so I recorded it and compared it with his recording. The recorded version is understandably more conservative than his live perfomance but this takes away some of the exuberance of the youthful Brahms. Roaring octaves in the live performance become clean cut, controlled octaves in the recording. If this were any other pianist's recording I would drool over it, yet this is Stephen Hough and I want more. I expect something extra special when anything comes from Hough's Hyperion recording camp. For those seeking the ultimate Brahms Op.5, have a listen to Clifford Curzon's recording on Decca.
The Ballades are excellently performed and recorded, and I particularly enjoyed the floating 4th."
How is it possible to score anything less than five stars?
Avid Reader | Franklin, Tn | 02/06/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This recording is a tour de force - that's the only words to describe it. I admit that I am an avid fan of Stephen Hough and his virtuosic yet musical (two terms not always found together) interpretations. In this case he takes the magnificent Fifth Sonata in F Minor (my favorite) and delivers with a "Brahmsian" touch. In many hands this has been heavy and even dull, but Hough keeps the focus on the melodies, perfect phrasing. As much as I enjoyed the sonata, the Ballades were even better (if possible). The dreamlike state sometimes associated with Brahms's piano works has never been realized as it is in this recording. This is a definitive CD for any collection."
YOUTH
GEORGE RANNIE | DENVER, COLORADO United States | 04/18/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Previously, I've always, in my mind, kind of thought of Brahms as only being very much of a heavily bearded rather severe, stoic older man-one who reportedly was an old curmudgeon. However, as with all of us, he was indeed young once. The compositions on this album are from his youth. Stephen Hough's playing gives off, to me, the very aura of youth-none of the Brahmnistic "heaviness "of his old age. The "glow" that only someone that is young can have-time had not dulled his hopes, joys, etc. In other word life still had much hope and promise. Hough plays the 5th sonata in F minor wonderfully-for once my attention did not wonder. He truly plays it phenomenally. What technique. The Opus 10 works are wonderful too and Stephen Hough never loses sight of the fact that they too are rather "young Brahms". Stephen always maintains a keen sense of hope and transparency-no later heaviness.
If you want to hear some great "young" Brahms, buy this disc.
"