A very nice suprise of lovers of Brahms' Symphony 1
F. Behrens | Keene, NH USA | 04/19/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Naxos has just issued the latest entry in their series of Brahms' (8.55419), this one offering us the mighty and the meretricious. I had not known that Brahms had reduced his "Symphony No. 1" to a piano piece for four hands. While it certainly will never replace that remarkable work, it can stand on its own as an independent work of art and a welcome substitute for the fully orchestrated version, which I have heard once too often in my lifetime. The "Triumphlied" that fills out the program is a 22-minute piece of jingoism celebrating Brahms' beloved Bismarck and his conquest over the French back in 1870. I believe that the composer was sincere but that he did not find much deep musical inspiration in the events that prompted this work. I am sure it sounds even more blatantly propagandistic in its original version for baritone, chorus and orchestra. I don't dislike it, mind you; but anything in praise of slaughter always leaves a sour taste for me. Pianists Silke-Thora Matthies and Christian Kohn make a good case for both works. And the ultimate decision is, of course, yours to make."