A good reference
Gorky | 02/04/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Walter recorded his Brahms cycle in 1960 and the sound recording is as good as what we may have today. The reason of it, Walter had a real sense of the polyphony which is characterized by the perfect balance between violin and cello ( i do not agree too much with Amazon that bass are heavy, i would say deep, and use a good set of headphones) and the sound deployed by his orchestra is the most adapted for Brahms symphonies, where alternance of bass and treble strings are permanent. This is always the version i install on my CD player since it is the most natural and sounds, melody go straight to your heart. There is no secret: listen for the first time, if it is good it should "tilt", and this one does! I got many others (famous Kleiber version, Szell....) but this one is by far my favourite. Sony did a perfect remastering like they did for most of stereo records of the Walter Edition, keeping sound of the Columbia orchestra natural and impressive. We can recommend this record for his authenticity and believe me, it is brilliant. Definitely a reference."
The most exciting "Tragic Overture" on disc?
niveditahr | 07/31/1999
(4 out of 5 stars)
"An exciting and skilled interpretation of Brahms' "Tragic Overture". Walter's control of the orchestra is superb. This is one of those occasions where the performance rises above the music. The recording of the fourth symphony is good, but not great. Kleiber (on DG) Haitink with Boston (on Philips) are better. Buy this disc for the "Tragic Overture"."