Essential collection
L. Johan Modée | Earth | 09/17/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Bruno Walter. Mahler's disciple and protégé. His reputation as a Mahler conductor is unmatched (though Klemperer and Mengelberg come close). This set contains nothing but essential Walter CBS recordings, even if it is a pity that the set, as such, is incomplete. First, Walter's very fine CBS account of Das Lied von der Erde is excluded. Second, his outstanding mono take of the first symphony with NYPO, for CBS, is missing.
What we have here are nonetheless recordings that belong in every Mahlerite collection. It is good to have them all in a set - for saving money, for example. And it is nowadays almost impossible to find the present performance of ninth symphony as a single set (blame SONY for their policy).
Some comments:
Symphony 1 & 2: outstanding early stereo takes (no. 1, rec. 1961, no. 2, rec. 1958) with classic, warm interpretations that leave very little to wish.
Symphony 4 & 5: two mono takes (rec. 1946), but indeed essential even for hifi enthusiasts. Clearly among the very best and classic performances of these works.
Symphony 9: Walter made the first live recording of this symphony in 1938 (available on EMI or Naxos). But this is the first stereo recording of the ninth (rec. 1961). The interpretation is second to none.
Grab this set while it's available!
"
Five classic Walter performances, three in stereo!
J. Gillon | North Carolina | 08/07/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This is (at least as long as it's available) an easy and inexpensive way to obtain the fine 1961 1st and 1958 2nd stereo performances (available as ASIN: B000002A7H) and the hard-to-find steroe 9th (ASIN: B000002A7K) along with mono performances of the 4th and 5th. The individual performances included here are much-reviewed elsewhere and I will spare you the redundancy of further comment, but suffice it to say that every one of these performances is a classic. Sound quality is fine. Enthusiastically recommended."