Koopman Shines in Buxtehude's Organ Works
Paul Van de Water | Virginia, USA | 10/26/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Buxtehude's organ works have been well treated by recording companies. Rene Saorgin (on Harmonia Mundi), Harald Vogel (on MD&G), Bine Bryndorf (on DaCapo), Hans Davidsson (on Loft, in progress), Wolfgang Rubsam et al. (on Naxos), and Walter Kraft (on Vox) have all set down the entire opus. Now comes the Dutch conductor and organist Ton Koopman, who is recording the organ compositions as part of the first complete set of all of Buxtehude's works (opera omnia).
Whether you are a long-time admirer of Buxtehude or would like to make his aquaintance, you will find Koopman's recordings of these organ pieces hard to resist. Koopman shines in the large, freely composed works (praeludia, toccatas, and chorale fantasias) and propels the music forward with tempos that are generally a bit faster than average. In the less flamboyant choral preludes, he maintains interest with a variety of registrations. Each volume in the series is recorded on a different historic organ, and the sound is top-notch.
Interestingly, Koopman has recorded this first volume of his cycle in 2006 on the same organ in Altenbruch, Germany, that Rene Saorgin used to record part of his traversal around 1970. The Saorgin recording still sounds great and provides more of the ambience of the venue. Saorgin's 5-CD set was out of print for a while but has recently been re-released René Saorgin Plays Buxtehude. You won't go wrong with either Saorgin or Koopman. Davidsson's recordings on the new north German baroque-style organ in Goteborg, Sweden, are good, too, but seem less inspired.
Volume 2 Dieterich Buxethude: Organ Works, Vol. 2 and volume 3 Complete Works 8: Organ Works of this cycle are now also available from Amazon. Volume 4 is available on the Challenge Classics website."