Overwhelmingly beautiful
Leslie Richford | Selsingen, Lower Saxony | 10/13/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I have only heard the Mass for Five Voices with motets and excerpts from the Gradualia from a previous single CD edition (= the first CD of this set), so I cannot comment on this entire edition. But as for what I have heard: what beautiful music this is! The Sixteen is one of Britain's leading professional mixed choirs, and this production can be compared with those of the Tallis Scholars: superb voices, including a pure 'mean' (high soprano, here sung by females), a perfect feeling for this 'ancient' music (Byrd was a contemporary of Shakespeare), overwhelmingly beautiful both with 'the early Byrd' (motets) and the more meditative gradualia and mass pieces. The recording, made in 1988 at Boxgrove Abbey in England, is equally excellent.
Of course, there are different ways of performing Byrd's music, and some would prefer a puristic, one-voice-to-a-part approach (see for example the EMI Hilliard Ensemble recording). Others might consider using boy sopranos for the 'mean'. You just have to find out for yourself which approach you think adequately captures the spirit of this music. At all events, Byrd is the winner by this disc, which motivated me to move from Byrd's Catholic masses to his Anglican church music, his 'Great Service', of which there is an equally enthralling disc by the Tallis Scholars."