S. Patterson | Charelston, WV United States | 02/10/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"All I can say is that it is about time! Ever since the first time I heard these guys warm up I knew great things were gonna happen. This album has everything you would want in great metal album. Incredible druming. Incredible guitar work. Incredible vocals. It is all here. If you like Meshuggah, buy this album.
If you like Chimara, buy this album.
It is hard to write this review due to the fact it is hard to put into words how awesome these guys are. If you get a chance to see them live, check it out. It is like watching a car wreck as it happens you just can't look away.
So, if you are tired of what is out there and want to listen to an incredible musicians give this a spin. You will not be disappointed! Nuff said...."
3.5 Stars, but I'll round up.
K. Brigance | Where East Meets West | 06/27/2005
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Byzantine may have the best name in modern heavy metal; and here I thought people in West Virginia were slow-witted. Its also refreshing to see a young metal band focusing their songwriting on something other than the human body (or the dismemberment of) or (sob) self-or-ex-girlfriend-effacement. So as far as their non-musical influences are concerned, I am very impressed with Byzantine.
As for The Fundamental Component...a Prosthetic Records press release described them as an amalgam of Clutch, Slayer, and Meshuggah, interestingly enough its slightly accurate. Of course if you combined the first two bands (the American ones) you'd probably just get Prong. And that is precisely who Byzantine reminds of the most, albeit a much more Meshuggah-influenced Prong. Its thick and meaty, but it isn't afraid to be literate or legible.
The Fundamental Component starts very strong with 'Hatfield' and the trend continues. I'd say the first time I cringed when listening to this album came when I heard the clean-vocaled chorus of 'Stoning Judas'. Until that point I had been intrigued, but then they had to go all emo-metal for a second (luckily its only a few small fragments of the album). I personally do not like the whole clean and catchy mixed with pummelingly heavy trend that is occurring in Amercian metal, and The Fundamental Component is muuuuuuuch better than any Killswitch Engage or As I Lay Dying record ever will be. It just seemed like a very intelligent and talented band was dumbing-down their sound for a brief moment in order to quickly catch the attention of some 16-year old Hot Topic customer.
Other than that, it is a very strong techinical-metal album; certainly better and fresher than the last two Meshuggah albums. It is understandable why Lamb of God's Chris Adler took a liking to this band. This album has about 8 and 1/2 good songs out of the ten. Hopefully the next album will feature less singing, more solos (because this guy can shred), and maybe a slightly beefed-up drum sound. Overall I can only see this band getting better, but then again, I've been wrong."
Crushing math-metal
Chris | West Lafayette, IN | 02/11/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"First I have to say I DO hope more bands like this come out of WV!! It's about time someone from good ole' WV gets the recognition they deserve (hillbilly metal? PLEASE!). Byzantine combines crushing music with thoughtful lyrics and a darn good singer. Don't get me wrong - I like death metal, but I also like to hear a heavy band with a singer that actually has some variety. OJ can sing, scream, growl like Satan, whatever the song calls for. If this is what you want, look no further! All the musicians are extremely talented (especially the drummer;)), and the songs are well-crafted. Good solos too. This is "thinking man's metal" all the way. Not for the faint of heart or the mentally challenged."
Whine, whine, whine.
I | Indiana | 07/19/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Seriously, these guys are getting unwarranted bullcrap from people. 3 bad reviews in a row? Unfortunately, it looks like ANOTHER band has been added to the "It's cool to hate them for no reason just to sound like I'm only into heavy underground bands" list. Along with Cradle of Filth, DevilDriver, Korn, Judas Priest, Killswitch Engage, etc. For some reason, complete rip-offs like Unearth can get away with murder, just so long as EVERYBODY approves of them. These guys are talented, stop the bashing, commence with the listening."
A must-own!
Jared Tuk | Pittsburgh, PA United States | 02/12/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"To think that a debut effort from a band who doesn't come from a "scene" can be this good only belies the unlimited potential from these outstanding musicians. This record sounds like "Byzantine," regardless of what other reviewers have said. This is a band that when you hear the first measure of music, you know exactly who is playing it. I consider myself fortunate to also call these guys friends. I have heard a number of other songs from them over the past several years that I can only hope will someday see the record store shelves. The collective creativity and sheer musical genius of this band will carry them to the masses, and my prediction is that someday the critics of this cd will be lining up to dine on the feast of American metal that is BYZANTINE."