Good but not great
Aggressive Arms | Philadelphia, PA USA | 05/18/2009
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Mr. Cooper, the reviewer above, has it right. This is a good but not great ECM release. If you're fan of trumpet post-Miles Davis, Tomasz Stanko is better: more sensitive rhythmically and more interesting melodically. If you're looking for more pulse-driven contemporary European jazz, Nik Bartsch's Ronin is better. This record is decent, though, I don't want to knock it; only a couple of the tracks will fail to hold your attention."
Norway's Christian Scott?
Anthony Cooper | Louisville, KY United States | 01/23/2009
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Mathias Eick's debut album is defined by Eick's minimalistic playing. The typical song takes a spare melody, piano reminiscent of Keith Jarrett, often a bass ostinato, and a gradual build until the trumpet is soaring and the drums are playing a steady beat. I think five songs work well -- "The Door", "Cologne Blues", "October", "Williamsburg", and "Fly", while the rest are just okay. Christian Scott's "Album" CD is similar, but there are differences. Mathias Eick is less bluesy, and the rhythms on "The Door" are more straight-forward. If some minimal, melodic, Radiohead-influenced jazz trumpet sounds good, pick this up. It will probably also appeal to people who aren't totally jazz fans."