Historic, but pretty average, recording
Eric C. Sedensky | Madison, AL, US | 01/03/2009
(3 out of 5 stars)
"This recording is indispensable for Ellington fans, big band fans, and serious jazz music aficionados, but I think for the most part, the uneven recording quality and excessive tracks of pretty meaningless introductions, not to mention the riot quelling track, sort of miss the point and, I think, detract from the music. Sure, some of the solos are really hot, and the recording assures that the subtleties and intricacies of what was no doubt an epic performance are not lost, but still, how many times do we need to hear Duke's introduction? For me, the big selling point of this work is the liner notes, which are jam packed with photos, original liners, extensive musician and soloist listings, plus updated liners and session notes. I doubt there is an Ellington fan who wouldn't learn something by reading these notes once through. Long and short, I would say most casual fans can make do with the one CD set which eliminates most of the talking tracks and intros, but serious fans should go ahead and get this one. For pure music, this is not the greatest, but for jazz history and documentation, it is unsurpassed.
"
Where are the liner notes?
Benissimo | Rome, Italy | 04/17/2009
(4 out of 5 stars)
"The back cover of the CD mentions new extensive liner notes by Phil Schaap. Where are they? Inside I find only a listing of the track breakpoints and a miniature version of the original liner notes. Nothing by Schaap."