Search - Antonin Dvorak, Recorded Sound, Richard [1] Strauss :: Dvorák: Cello Concerto; R. Strauss: Don Quixote

A superstar cellist at his best

Santa Fe Listener | Santa Fe, NM USA | 11/05/2007

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Because of his association with Martha Argerich and his own great talents, Mischa Maisky has made dozens of high profile recordings, and with the recent passing of Rostropovich, he bids fair to be the superstar cellist one thinks of right behind Yo-Yo Ma. This pairing of the Dvorak concerto and Don Quixote came out in 2004, but it didn't turn into a high-profile release. It's easy to see why. Given the cello's limited solo repertoire with orchestra, the competition couldn't be more intense.



Even so, this is a wonderful release, in no small part because of the great Berlin players and the lavish sound from DG's engineers. I have never heard a warmer-sounding recording, and it's a joy to catch the nuances of Maisky's tone. He is a musician of touch rather htan force or charisma (compared, that is, to Rostropovich and De Pre), which is all to the good in the Dvorak. Warhorses must be revived with fresh phrasing and new insights, and Maisky brings both. Mehta offers discreet accompaniment, choosing not to go too symphonic.



Because the conductor carries much greater weight in Don Quixote, Mehta's so-so interpretation, which starts out too calm and mostly stays that way, can't stand up to Karajan or Kempe. The saving grace is the recorded soun and the Berliners, as before. But violist Tabea Zimmermann equals Maisky in musicality, so once they enter, the picture brightens. Maisky is somewhat more romantic and yielding than Ma with Maazel, but you can still tell that this is a cool, modernist reading. Here, Quixote speaks in mutters and sighs that are uncannily human. Fortunatley, the death of Quixote is played wth very touching gentleness. In all, this CD shouldn't be allowed to fall between the cracks -- it's very satisfying."

Contra Santa Fe listener

ears24seven | Albany, NY United States | 12/07/2008

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Maisky is a fantastic cellist, and a serious artist, "behind" Ma only in the latter cellist's love of kitsch, or the coin it brings in. What makes this record a must have, however, is the opportunity to hear Zubin Mehta's magnificent Strauss with a cellist who isn't confused about his role in the work, but nevertheless provides a stunningly beautiful characterization of the Don.



In comparison to Mehta's Strauss, even his Strauss outings with the LA Phil of old, von Karajan's are a crude teutonic mess. Mehta's attention to detail, the clarity, canny sense of pace and breathtaking subtlety are a great antitodote to the blowsy, unbalanced "run-through" approach of von Karajan (whose Strauss in the pit was fortunately the opposite).



And the post-war German orchestras of von Karajan and Kempe? They got by on legend. Don't even get me started.



Any opportunity to hear Mehta in Strauss, jump on it, but Maisky and Mehta are especially beautifully synced in this record and the marvelous Tabea Zimmermann plays a wonderfully loyal Sancho Panza.



This record is a treasure, by which I will happily remember maestro Mehta's underrated genius long after he has gone, which I hope is not any time soon.



"