Under-rated and almost forgotten Dvorak, reissued.
J. K. Davis MD | Cleveland, Ohio | 06/13/2010
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I had to purchase three Decca "Duos" to get these; now comes a complete set. It's fascinating how some performances, such as the Kertesz, dominate the market for years while others virtually go into oblivion. It's hard to say what the finest recordings of symphonies 7-9 are, since these are great music to begin with and there TONS of excellent recordings. The first four symphonies require some advocacy by the conductor and orchestra, and these are terrific performances with better sound than the Kertesz or Kubelik of similar vintage. The only other set which comes close in the early symphonies in my view is that of Otmar Suitner, formerly hard to find but now available from Berlin Classics. My favorites are actually the fifth and sixth, because in part I haven't heard them as much as the last three
"great" symphonies, and Rowicki and Suitner score ahead of the two more famous sets there as well."
Great Dvorak
Russell Etzenhouser | 05/21/2010
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Rowicki contributes a very exciting and well balanced set. He is very well recorded and is not afraid to keep things moving along. I first heard this set on LP in the 1980's. His recording of the first symphony will always be the ideal for me. While Kertesz and Kubelik are often ranked ahead of Rowicki, I don't think that either one does the whole series as well as Rowicki."