Search - Eddi Reader :: Simple Soul

Marginal

Anonymous | 08/18/2003

(3 out of 5 stars)

"I'll admit I like to have my own personal Women's Music Festival at my desk in the office every once in a while, but the recent glut of female singer/songwriters has made them a dime a dozen and I was a bit disappointed. I won't say I'm shutting the door in Eddi Reader, 'cause I'd heard good things about her, but I heard very little in the CD to distinguish her from a million other acoustic folksingers.She has a few great lyrics, but none of the sophisitication of early Suzanne Vega; she can't match with the quirkiness of Dar Williams or the Nields; doesn't have the sharp wit of softer Ani Difranco (can't really compare harder Ani to this); obviously can't harmonize like the Indigo Girls; doesn't have a really distinctive voice like Kristin Hersh or Mary Fahl; no jazzy savoir faire like Erin McKeown or Amy Correia. It's not a BAD album, and I respect the effort, it's just not exciting and therefore there's no real reason to keep it from sitting in the back of my cd rack, while I play others I can't get enough of."

Light Touch

Aaron Wong | Sydney, Australia | 01/16/2002

(3 out of 5 stars)

"A lot of singers show buckets of technical or artistic vocal talent but come up short on interesting material. Eddi Reader though a sorceress with all 3 powers, continues with expectation, and does not try and prove what she's proven before. This recording may not fit your mood, but it is still worth listening to for the amount of heart in the singing as well as the words.Every review so far is right. Those wanting to hear a more energetic Eddi will be disappointed. The concept here, as indicated by the album title, is a pared down approach to musicianship and arrangements. This won't be my favourite Eddi album. I could use a big epic number like "Dolphins" or "Kiteflyer's Hill", and others may long for the more standard stylings of Fairground Attraction. On the other hand, if you are prepared to listen, this album will reward in its own unrushed way. In mood and thought it achieves what it sets out to do. The singer sincerely shares her thoughts, and her quiet art here is as masterly and uncopied and beautiful as ever. Also significant to note, unlike other recordings of popular solo artists, the musicians here sparkle and do not take a back seat to the star. You'll be mesmerised with the opening to the song "Adam", and warm to the acoustic jangle and very human foibles contained within "Wanting Kind"."