This is the recording of Erwartung to buy
J. P. Anderson | Houston, TX USA | 08/07/2002
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This CD joins two very different works of Schoenberg, both from before he started writing his 12-tone works. The Brettl-Lieder were written early in his career (though after Verklaerte Nacht), while he was working with a cabaret company. The songs are light, humorous, stylized, arch, and rather unlike what you expect to hear from Schoenberg. The first seven are for piano and voice, but the last adds piccolo, trumpet, and snare drum. Jesse Norman does a great job with these. Although these songs are well-suited to lighter voices than Jesse's, she scales her voice down and digs into the cabaret style.Of course, the major work here is Erwartung, written a few years later. This "monodrama" is a one-act opera for a singer and orchestra. The story is of a woman wandering through a moonlit forest looking for her lover who has not arrived at her house (and who may be with another woman). She is frightened, jealous, perhaps mad, and the story must be interpreted from the fleeting thoughts she vocalizes. She stumbles across a heavy object in the darkness. Is it his body? Is he dead? Did she kill him?Jesse is wonderful in this role. Before this recording, she had performed the opera at the Metropolitan Opera, conducted by James Levine. It was paired with Bartok's one-act Bluebeard's Castle (with Sam Ramey). The operas were broadcast on PBS, which was a bold move away from Boheme and Carmen. Jesse Norman and James Levine play up the late Romanticism in this early Expressionist work. Schoenberg's music illustrates both the spooky, moonlit wood and the woman's unhinged, wandering thoughts. These artists capture this perfectly."
An intriguing look at musical Expressionism
John Harrington | 09/27/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Schoenberg's "Erwartung" is an Expressionist type composition with a psychoanalytic look at feminine hysteria. The fact that the main female character remains nameless is an attempt at making the ideas presented in the piece cross time and space. Schoenberg's many musical ideas allowed for much of the progression of twentieth century music as we know it today. Along with the other Expressionist ideals, "Erwartung" is rife with emphasis placed on melodic fragmentation and discontinuity, including the idea that a single word can mean as much as an entire sentence. No, Shoenberg was no mediocre composer, and was also an excellent painter and playwright as well. It was Schoenberg that brought the twelve-tone ideas into use, and who crossed many musical genres, from Post-Romanticism to Symbolism to Expressionism and beyond. "Erwartung" is definitely a psychological thriller, and the two terrified shrieks made by the leading lady along with the orchestra are definitely on par with the artists of the time, most notably Edward Munch's "The Scream," and who attempted to distort reality to find the essential truths within."
Track Listings (17) - Disc #1
Carol S. from PARADISE, CA