Alternate Take Overkill
Michael B. Richman | Portland, Maine USA | 12/10/2000
(4 out of 5 stars)
""The Complete Gerry Mulligan Meets Ben Webster Sessions" is the perfect example of why some classic jazz albums should be left alone, and why some bonus material should just stay in the vaults. There is no disputing that "GM Meets BW" is an all-time great session, and kudos to Verve for still making it available as a single CD. That disc combined the original six LP masters with five songs from the session that were previously unreleased. This "Complete" two-disc set basically adds another entire disc's worth of alternate takes for eight of those eleven tunes, including three (!) each of "Fajista," "Go Home," and "The Cat Walk." We are not talking about the "Legendary Charlie Parker Dial Sessions" here, where every alternate version produced a different Parker solo and allowed you to see a great improviser at work. The Ben and Jeru alternates are valuable, but most people will skip around them (as I often do). Don't get me wrong, I think that it is great that Verve is taking the time to assemble quality releases of historical significance. (This same initiative led to the release of the amazing three-CD "Complete Lee Konitz Motion Sessions" which did have a plethora of unreleased gems.) I just don't think "The Complete Gerry Mulligan Meets Ben Webster Sessions" is for everyone."