"My perfect antidote to any form of depression: The irreverent side of Glenn Gould, deconstructing the hallowed Appassionata sonata, showing that the emperor, in this case, was without clothes.
The whole record is perceptive, revealing new insights (and opinions) on Beethoven`s music. But it is not a representative Beethoven piano recording, and should be supplemented with one of the many excellent "correct" recordings that exist - Alfred Brendel is but one example.
This is for those who appreciate Gould`s unique and always fresh way of making music come alive and speak to you. Enjoy!"
"Shakespeare and Beethoven are two powerful examples that show that no matter you face his work, even how terrible you play his message they resist as a big tree any intention, they simply are far beyond the present circumstance, they talk to the best of ourselves and the power of synthesis and strong conviction make them indestructible.
Glenn Gould's approach is an irreverent reading, trying to diminish the epic in some Sonatas and emphasizing the grief and passion. That's why the whole sum can produce great positive surprises but also terrible disappointments. For instance I love his version of the Op. 49, The Adieux, The Funeral March, Second, third and Seventh Sonatas, and even the Moonlight, the Tempest and the op. 110, because somehow this last Sonata reflects more than any other else the intimate universe of Mr.Gould.
I mean, do not expect glorious results from the Waldstein or Hamerklavier. I know Gould to guess he could do a best performance but simply didn ` t because his intention was clearly to refuse the argument lines and the historicity. I agree totally with him in what concerns with the absence of any Romantic approach with Beethoven, and in this sense he triumphs in several works due the true Beethovenian dissonances must sound hard, bitter and wild.
"
GET GOULD's BEETHOVEN!...
Sébastien Melmoth | Hôtel d'Alsace, PARIS | 05/22/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"GG does something with Beethoven: the voicing, the phrasing, the accents--all brilliantly insightful and ingenious. Not to mention GG's miraculous digital ability: he had skills like no other: he does things because he COULD do things. You see?
The Opp. 31s are great; but the real treat is the last great three sonatas Opp. 109-11. I have Pollini; I have Kempff--whom I usually prefer to anyone with Beethoven; still, Gould beats them all here. I just keep listening to GG's Opp. 109-11 over and over again. Each hearing reveals new exquisitenesses.
Also, the Appassionata here is read in a similar fashion to GG's realization of the HammerKalvier: magnificent. You have to put down your tired old prejudices, and come to the work of Art as an unique phenomenon. Understand?!"
Great Musician
Andrew Linton | Cleveland,TN | 04/18/2003
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Every Gould recording is an adventure and should be given at least one listen or more. The recording sound and playing style is so unique as are all of Gould's recordings."
Gould loves Beethoven
David Gillett | New York, NY USA | 05/15/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I just returned this CD set to the library; it was like saying goodbye to a dear friend. Other reviewers comment on Gould's irreverence. He isn't irreverent to Beethoven, but to the accumulated weight of two centuries of performance tradition. His approach is direct: just play the notes and let them guide you to an interpretation. Listening to other pianists play the same material is painful "Why slow down here? Why that sudden dynamic change?" Their "interpretations" seem fussy and intrusive.
The first movement of the Appassionata is the most obvious. I laughed through it the first time. All the drama is removed: a slap in the face to traditional interpretation. As I listened again and again, the somber magnificence of Beethoven's genius emerged. Gould explores every note and lets it speak. He never short-changes a passage to achieve an effect.
In his late sonatas, Beethoven became more contrapuntal. Gould shines in these movements, allowing the great fugues to build from their own internal strength, revealing the architecture.
I imagine Beethoven listening (if he somehow could) to these performances and saying (in German), "Of course! How else would you play it?""