Everything done right
Wes | World Citizen, Earth | 08/26/2006
(4 out of 5 stars)
"What an amazing band they were. Having just discovered "Fambly Cat" I sought out earlier albums and I am amazed at this one. Tracks 2-7 are absolute perfection. I've just spent the last few hours listening repeatedly, over and over and over again to "El Caminos In The West" - that is a song which is so perfect it is beyond belief. Everything about that song is done exactly right: production, cadence, tone. It is a brilliant example of what happens when everything just comes together and WORKS. I could listen to that track indefinitely and not tire of it. That is truly a great experience, to discover perfect songs like these and really feel them."
Surprisingly sharp behind the mediocre veneer
IRate | 09/14/2007
(3 out of 5 stars)
"3 1/2
A simplistic, yet deceptively deep alternative pop rock release from this recently disbanded group yields much in between the overt catchiness and sometimes corny production. Taking even the melodic simplicity (not to mention cheap) of "Stray Dog And The Chocolate Shake", one can see the band's unique talent for turning lemons into lemonade. Most songs drift in and out of the lethargic drumming with a surprising amount of thought put into the relatively simple chord progressions. In effect, Sumday certainly does not break any new ground, but emphasizes itself quite nicely, and consistently, with the limited vocabulary this band is dealing in. Fans of Mercury Rev and Sparklehorse in their more mellow modes should feel right at home."