Yet Another Messiah Recording
A. Craig | Grand Junction,CO | 01/28/2006
(3 out of 5 stars)
"Here we have another recording of Handel's Oratorio Messiah.
This recording uses the Watkins Shaw Edition of this work.
William Boughton and the English Symphony Orchestra and the Saint Michaels Singers, and the soloists deliver a fairly decent
performace. I only have a few quibbles with this recording. First the baritone Gavin Carr finds it necessary in the recitative "Thus Saith the Lord of Hosts" to sing the word "shake" over accenting the "k" in "shake" I personally find it a little annoying on repeated listening. The Saint Michaels Singers do an okay job with the choruses, but I prefer a slightly larger chorus for this work. The rest of the soloists
manage their parts reasonably well. As recordings of Messiah go this is an Fair to Good one, not a great one, but better than many others I have heard over the years, just not one of the really great ones."