Manuel Valderrama | Chicago, IL United States | 02/29/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"In this collection of bel canto favorites, Natalie Dessay gives us a record of the buzz she has been generating for several years. She is truly an intelligent singer with a powerful, appealing instrument. She navigates some of the most demanding coloratura passages with grace, courage,insight, and total musicality. Her Donizetti is particularly strong, particularly the selections from Maria Stuarda and Cap/Montecchi--but most amazing is her Mad Scene from Lucia. Her Verdi and Bellini selections are also impressive. It is too early to tell how well she shall be remembered given some of the earlier greats, but it is undeniable that she is extremely talented. In many ways she appears to combine the best qualities of Callas, Sutherland, Sills, and Anderson. Having seen her on stage years ago, I am happy to notice that the high quality of her acting does come through on record. This is a singer keep watching."
Splendid coloratura work
Steven A. Peterson | Hershey, PA (Born in Kewanee, IL) | 06/22/2008
(4 out of 5 stars)
"As I understand it, Natalie Dessay recently underwent surgery for nodes on her vocal chords. Hence, I was quite interested to listen to this CD, to see if this had affected her obvious gifts as a coloratura soprano, one of those high-flying phenomena. I even compared how she sounded here to some of her earlier recordings; for the most part, I don't really hear much of a difference (but my ears are quite untutored).
She reigns as one of the premier coloratura sopranos of the current era. I'm not sure that she ranks with Sumi Jo, but she surely ranks ahead of most others of her species. And her awesome high notes (listen to her in "Fruhlingstimmen," the Strauss waltz; that final note must be coming close to A above high C? Not quite Mado Robin-esque, but pretty impressive--and musical at the same time). . . . Here is a sampling of cuts from this CD.
"E strano!. . .Sempre libera." This segment from Verdi's "La Traviata" is a wonderful work. She begins this nicely, in "E strano!," an aria sung well and affectingly (from videos that I have seen, she appears to be a good singing actress). How about her performance in the cabaletta, "Sempre libera"? She seems in command of this piece, and her singing is quite satisfactory indeed. There is a bit of harshness here and there, but not a critical problem. A solid high note to close out. Overall, nicely done.
"Vien diletto." If I were to create a collection of my favorite cabalettas from opera, this piece from Bellini's "I Puritani" would be on that list. The first run through is smoothly sung, albeit at a deliberate pace. The repeat? She amps it up. Much more florid singing, including nice staccato singing and interpolation of higher notes. No trills, to my regret (I know, I should not impose what I'd like to hear on an artist's interpretation, but. . . .). Well done, with a nice final high note.
"Nella pace del mesto ripose." This is from one of Donizetti's operas, "Maria Stuarda," another nice entry in the coloratura soprano repertoire. Overall, smoothly sung, with considerable vocal agility. Midway through, some ugly sounds, as her voice gets awfully harsh on a couple high volume high notes (a la the late Callas, whose voice spun out of control in such circumstances). Still, she recovers well and concludes with a set of solid high notes.
The final cut I'll look at--my favorite cabaletta of all, "Spargi d'amaro pianto," from Donizetti's "Lucia di Lammermoor." For those who are interested: Yes, she sings the Italian and not the French version (hearing Dessay sing this in French is weird, since I have memorized the Italian lines from the cabaletta); yes, the orchestra uses the glass harmonica (according to the liner notes). The first go through is taken at a rather slow pace, but Dessay sings well. The repeat? More florid singing (as one would hope), staccato singing, a decent trill, fine agility, and a solid final high note. Not sure that her high notes are quite as stunning as before surgery, but she still does well closing out an aria.
And, there is a bonus! One also gets with this a DVD of her Metropolitan Opera performance of this opera in September, 2007. It's sometimes fun to watch as well as listen to opera singing. The pace from this performance is peppier than that on the CD. From what I can tell, she is a fine actress for an opera singer (compare her acting performance in videos with Joan Sutherland's in the Mad Scene). When she repeats "Spargi," she shows good staccato singing, a nice trill, and good vocal agility. Nice final high note.
So? A good compilation of recent operatic works by Natalie Dessay. And the DVD is a nice bonus.
"
"Beware the Fortissimo Top Notes"
Stanley H. Nemeth | Garden Grove, CA United States | 05/06/2008
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Natalie Dessay is beyond question a singer of prodigious coloratura gifts. Her vocal fireworks, the seemingly tossed off, astonishingly accurate passages of scales and arpeggios, are appropriately breathtaking. Further when she sings softly, her voice is both dramatic, yet consistently beautiful. If there is a flaw in her voice, I would say it's the piercing, almost factory-whistle like vibrato which marks her stratospheric topmost notes when sung fortissimo. To hear her both at her best and weakest, I would point to the "Maria Stuarda" selection. The aria itself is sung just about to perfection, as is most of the cabaletta. In the middle section of the latter, however, Dessay produces a couple of the loud high notes I've referred to, the sort that could take paint right off a wall. Happily, in her recent "Sonnambula" recording she avoided this sort of blood-curdling, let it rip, frankly ugly high note, though it was prominent in her complete "Lucia," unfortunately.
For my money, the softly sung selections on this present recording are the standouts. The slow part of the "Stuarda" aria, and most of all, the wonderful "I Capuleti" excerpt are reasons enough for purchasing the set."
Mad Scene triumph
W. sloan | 12/29/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"My wife and I saw Ms.Dessay perform Lucia at the Paris Opera in a non-traditional production. We thought it was fabulous, but the DVD of her performance at the Met in a traditional staging may be even better. Although there are a few misses in her singing,the overall effect leaves you in tears. The combination of acting-and I have seen Dame Joan, Lily Pons, Anna Moffo and Maria Callas in person-and singing is unbeatable. I do hope this production is released in its entirety. I enjoyed the CD but the DVD is the reason to buy this product."
Brilliant Soprano
Bella Figura | Westerly, RI | 05/31/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This is just an outstanding recording. Thankfully, the future of opera is safe with the voice of Ms. Dessay. The lovely DVD of her Lucia "mad scene" is just grand. A noble addition to my library."