J.J. Johnson was the first trombonist to demonstrate that bop could even be played on trombone, using his stellar technique to negotiate twisting, high-speed heads and to generate the lithe, rapid-fire lines associated wit... more »h saxophones and trumpets. Along with acclaim and frequent imitation, he was also met with criticism for sounding mechanical. As this CD amply demonstrates, though, Johnson wasn't an unfeeling technician, but a subtly expressive player, a master of understatement who could substitute a restrained slur and a lightly muffled note for the trombone's often exaggerated bray. His expressive qualities are much in evidence on the two quintet sessions from 1954 and 1955 paired on this CD. The first six tracks have the trombonist accompanied by a superb rhythm section of pianist Wynton Kelly, bassist Charles Mingus, and drummer Kenny Clarke, with conga drummer Sabu Martinez adding a Latin touch. The emphasis is on standards, with Johnson swinging lightly on "Too Marvelous for Words," building a tropical fantasy on "Old Devil Moon," and creating moments of gorgeous languor on "Its You or No One" and "Time After Time." The 1955 session has Johnson and Clarke joined by burgeoning heavyweights of the hard-bop movement--tenor saxophonist Hank Mobley, pianist Horace Silver, and bassist Paul Chambers--and it's a terrific combination. Johnson and Mobley fuse into a mellow team, and there are opportunities for both the boppish sides of the band ("Viscosity"), and its bluesy side, with Johnson's "Groovin'" inspiring some characteristically soulful playing from Silver. Rudy Van Gelder was the original engineer on these sessions, and his digital remastering has done wonders to the overall sound and definition of each instrument. His new input is especially notable on the earlier material, where Clarke's and Sabu's drums now stand in clear as well as close relationship to one another. --Stuart Broomer« less
J.J. Johnson was the first trombonist to demonstrate that bop could even be played on trombone, using his stellar technique to negotiate twisting, high-speed heads and to generate the lithe, rapid-fire lines associated with saxophones and trumpets. Along with acclaim and frequent imitation, he was also met with criticism for sounding mechanical. As this CD amply demonstrates, though, Johnson wasn't an unfeeling technician, but a subtly expressive player, a master of understatement who could substitute a restrained slur and a lightly muffled note for the trombone's often exaggerated bray. His expressive qualities are much in evidence on the two quintet sessions from 1954 and 1955 paired on this CD. The first six tracks have the trombonist accompanied by a superb rhythm section of pianist Wynton Kelly, bassist Charles Mingus, and drummer Kenny Clarke, with conga drummer Sabu Martinez adding a Latin touch. The emphasis is on standards, with Johnson swinging lightly on "Too Marvelous for Words," building a tropical fantasy on "Old Devil Moon," and creating moments of gorgeous languor on "Its You or No One" and "Time After Time." The 1955 session has Johnson and Clarke joined by burgeoning heavyweights of the hard-bop movement--tenor saxophonist Hank Mobley, pianist Horace Silver, and bassist Paul Chambers--and it's a terrific combination. Johnson and Mobley fuse into a mellow team, and there are opportunities for both the boppish sides of the band ("Viscosity"), and its bluesy side, with Johnson's "Groovin'" inspiring some characteristically soulful playing from Silver. Rudy Van Gelder was the original engineer on these sessions, and his digital remastering has done wonders to the overall sound and definition of each instrument. His new input is especially notable on the earlier material, where Clarke's and Sabu's drums now stand in clear as well as close relationship to one another. --Stuart Broomer
Paul Duynhouwer | Boca Raton, Florida United States | 09/23/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"These two albums from the mid-50"s are among the very best ever recorded by the master of the modern jazz trombone. J.J. shines throughout with his immaculate phrasing and musical logic, and his sidemen, especially Kenny Clarke and Wynton Kelly, back him beautifully. A must for the trombone afficianado, this treasure contains swinging blues, mellow ballads and rejuvenated standards that make one nostalgic for the days when coherence, thorough preparation and unpretensiousness were king. As Duke said--it don't mean a thing when it ain't got that swing! Highly recommended."
An Album That Lives Up To Its Title
Michael B. Richman | Portland, Maine USA | 05/16/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"When the name of your album is "The Amazing Bud Powell," "The Fabulous Fats Navarro" or "The Eminent J.J. Johnson," you'd better live up to the billing. Well, J.J. does! This, the second volume of "Eminent," was originally released on Blue Note as two 10-inch records. The CD compiles two seesions, one from September 1954 and the other from June 1955, with three alternates that were not origianlly released. The first six tunes are from the '54 session featuring Mingus(!), Wynton Kelly, Kenny Clarke and Sabu on congas. These recordings are good, but they bother me because I've never met a jazz conga player that I've liked. The remaining tunes are from a band with that true Blue Note sound, which could hold its own against any of the period, including the original Jazz Messengers (of course, two of them are here). Johnson, Hank Mobley, Horace Silver, Paul Chambers and Kenny Clarke are in top form (aren't they always!), especially on "Viscosity" and "Groovin'." While "The Eminent J.J. Johnson, Volume Two" might not be a unanimous selection to the jazz album hall of fame like its predescor "Volume One," it is definitely not to be missed."
Two classic sessions from one of the greats
jazzfanmn | St Cloud, MN United States | 07/29/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"More great work for Blue Note by the master of the slide trombone. The personnell backing Mr Johnson for these two sets is about as formidable as one can find. The line up for the first six tracks has no less than Charles Mingus on bass, Wynton Kelly on piano, Kenny Clarke on drums and Sabu on congas. The second set adds a second horn in Hank Mobley, Horace Silver on piano, Paul Chambers on bass, while retaining Clarke on drums. Mr Johnson leads the groups with his formidable technique on his relativly clumsy solo instrument. Equally adept at nimble bop runs as tender muted statments, Johnson's talents are on full display. The music itself runs from early afro cuban/jazz fusion and Jazz Messanger flavored funky hard bop to tender ballad readings. A definate must for all bop fans, as well as those of the personnell."
"Preeminent" is more like it.
Samuel Chell | Kenosha,, WI United States | 07/11/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"These sessions marked J. J.'s return to jazz following a two-year hiatus, during which time J. J. worked as a blueprint inspector, seeking a more secure livelihood than what jazz could offer. Before disappearing from the music scene he had already recorded with practically all the major modernists, won the major jazz polls, and toured with Jazz at the Philharmonic. So these Blue Note sessions were delivered with serious purpose and intent by an artist who was as much about business as pleasure. Following these dates, he would sign on with Columbia in 1956, and thereafter would release dozens of albums with Kai Winding and other trombone players for Columbia, Bethlehem, Impulse, etc., practically becoming a household word. Even this popularity was not enough to guarantee him the secure, dependable income he sought, leading to another extended sabbatical from the trombone as he next found himself immersed in the Hollywood studios, devoting his time to writing and arranging.
A listener overwhelmed by J. J.'s prolific output on record could do worse than these Blue Note sessions, which represent J. J. with his game face on. He's joined by no more than a rhythm section or second compatible horn (Hank Mobley, who makes a more supportive frontline associate than a frontliner like Clifford Brown, the main second horn on Volume One). The one "suspect" tune on the date, "Pennies from Heaven," is not as cliched and tired as a listener might imagine before hearing it, and Mobley helps insure that the always elegant and genteel J. J. maintains his eminence as the most thoughtful and soulful of trombonists as well.
Complement this one with the Columbia collection, "Trombone Master," and you'll have a solid initial representation of the foremost exponent of the jazz trombone.
(Oops. I barely post what I regard as an "objective" review based on the best information I can find plus a lifetime's worth of hours listening to J. J. and countless numbers of other trombonists. I hope the individual who objects to the review does us all a favor by setting the record straight. Maybe Glenn Miller is the only trombonist who merits the description "preeminent.")"
Richman is Correct
Darrell Cleland | sacramento, ca | 07/24/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"J.J.Johnson is one of the greatest jazz trombonists who has ever lived. If you can find on CD an album called "Early Bones" you will find some miraculous duets played by Kai Winding and J.J. Johnson. Also worth purchasing. Three cheers for Mr. Richman who obviously knows his jazz."