Just... not good.
G.M. | 10/27/2009
(2 out of 5 stars)
"After a few listens, I just can't see how anyone over the age of 15 could really take this record seriously. I really don't understand what Mr. Sonic Youth sees in this - unless he's thinking Ms. Pearl can be the next maturity-step for fans who grew too old for Miley Cyrus, but are not quite ready for Yeah Yeah Yeahs. The lyrics are probably the worst element regarding this album. The lyrics are all so contrived and juvenile - trying to be edgy, seductive and sardonic but they emerge into a short spectrum that ranges from either silly to outright funny-ridiculous. Her faux-attitude still feels very contrived and 'plastic'. She's 22 now, but still writing material of that of a 16-year old. Which is fine if that's the age-group she's going for; however, I don't think it is. The music is fine, but nothing special. It's stuff you've heard one-hundred-thousand times over and over. Overall, I think it's just a waste. Although I think Ms. Pearl does have something to offer us, just not this time around."
Could be better...
Joy | 04/10/2010
(3 out of 5 stars)
"If you liked the rough sound of BYOP, Break it Up really isn't for you. Jemina's voice kind of sounds like Hilary Duff trying to be punk rock. And it just sounds annoying instead of hardcore or tough, which seems to be what she was aiming for.
Even Iggy's guest appearance on "I Hate People" doesn't redeem the album much, since he's just singing along to the melody in the background.
The reason I gave the album three stars is because some of the melodies are actually nifty. Two of my favorites are "Undesirable" and "Retrograde." I'm hoping, if she releases another album, her next CD will have more harmonies and less whining."