When John Prine wrote and recorded the likes of "Hello in There," "Angel from Montgomery," and "Souvenirs" in the early '70s, he came across like a Social Security recipient in a young man's body. As he revisits those tune... more »s and more favorites from his salad days, the wisdom Prine possessed as a twentysomething troubadour seems all the more remarkable. The raison d'être for Souvenirs may be rather prosaic. Prine rerecorded 15 early classics so that he could own master recordings of a bunch of songs from his first three albums, as well as a few stragglers from the late '70s and early '80s. But the flatteringly spare arrangements and Prine's wizened delivery only add weight to these heavy-hearted folk tunes. "It took me years to get those souvenirs / And I don't know how they slipped away from me," Prine sings on the title track, a remnant from 1972's Diamonds in the Rough. Well, John, they didn't slip away at all; they're still shining like gems under a layer of dust. --Steven Stolder« less
When John Prine wrote and recorded the likes of "Hello in There," "Angel from Montgomery," and "Souvenirs" in the early '70s, he came across like a Social Security recipient in a young man's body. As he revisits those tunes and more favorites from his salad days, the wisdom Prine possessed as a twentysomething troubadour seems all the more remarkable. The raison d'être for Souvenirs may be rather prosaic. Prine rerecorded 15 early classics so that he could own master recordings of a bunch of songs from his first three albums, as well as a few stragglers from the late '70s and early '80s. But the flatteringly spare arrangements and Prine's wizened delivery only add weight to these heavy-hearted folk tunes. "It took me years to get those souvenirs / And I don't know how they slipped away from me," Prine sings on the title track, a remnant from 1972's Diamonds in the Rough. Well, John, they didn't slip away at all; they're still shining like gems under a layer of dust. --Steven Stolder
Richard L Weintraut | WINSLOW, IN United States | 11/11/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"From the first clear ringing guitar notes of "Souvenirs", I knew that John Prine had made this recording for ME.ME, and all the people worldwide who love John Prine, sitting on a stool, guitar in hand, singing the songs that make us think, remember, shake our heads in wonder, sing along and smile.We can remember Steve Goodman as we listen to "Souvenirs".We remember that sometime in our life, deep down inside, we've all felt like Donald or Lydia.We remember loved ones as we listen to "Grandpa Was A Carpenter".And we sing along and smile to "Fish & Whistle and "Please Don't Bury Me".And most of all we shake our heads in wonder while we listen to these fifteen great songs.We wonder how someone whom we've never met can sit down and "write our feelings"...How does he know that we once had a relationship where..."Well ya know, she still laughs with me But she waits just a second too long...."Or that we all have known people who have lived through..."How the hell can a person Go to work in the morning And come home in the evening And have nothing to say..."We stop and think when we hear...."An old man sleeps with his conscience at night A young kid sleeps with his dreams While the mentally ill sit perfectly still And live through life's in betweens....These are not just "songs"... They mean something to us...I have all of John's recordings, I doubt if this one will ever leave my CD rotation...As I read this I find that it's not really a review of the album.It's really how I feel about John Prine.My favorite quote about John comes from Bonnie Raitt..."What makes John's songs so special is that there's no separating who he is from his music - you just love "him"..."He's a true folk singer in the best tradition, cutting right to the heart of things, as pure and simple as rain"That explains this recording.If you love John Prine, you must have this recording.If you've never heard of him... buy this recording.. then you'll love him too..."
This is REAL music!
Miles D. Moore | Alexandria, VA USA | 12/06/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"There's a whole herd of singer-songwriters out there--Steve Forbert, Robbie Fulks, Guy Clark, Townes Van Zandt--who have more talent individually than every combined member of every band on the Top 40, but who couldn't sell a CD if they parachuted naked with Madonna and Britney Spears onto the roof of Caesar's Palace. (Steve Earle and John Hiatt do a little better in the sales department, but not much.) Of this brilliant but unfortunate group, none is better than John Prine, and "Souvenirs" is a latter-day collection of some of his best songs. It takes chutzpah to write, "These songs are beautiful," at the beginning of your own liner notes, but in Prine's case he is only acknowledging the obvious. Songs like "Fish and Whistle," "Angel from Montgomery" and "Christmas in Prison" have the gritty, poignant inevitability we associate with the classic folk songwriters--Bob Dylan, Hank Williams, Woody Guthrie. Prine's blunt, tuneless voice--rather like Dylan's, but with a little more country and whiskey in it--is the perfect expressive instrument for these wonderful songs."
Deja-nirs
Anton R Dotson | Las Vegas, NV United States | 11/02/2000
(4 out of 5 stars)
"John Prine's newest disc is a collection of re-recordings of songs he has previously recorded/released over the last 30 years. His songs songs have worn well travelled paths in my musical landscape, the lyrics automatically spill forward as a song plays, comfortable and familiar. That familiarity can be a mixed blessing in this case. The new recordings are very similarly arranged compared to the originals, but not exactly so, throwing off my car karaoke timing,just enough; familiar but different. That's a nerdy fan's problem. Mr. Prine has assembled a wonderfully recorded batch of wonderful songs. His voice now has a more fragile and fleeting quality, almost like he's singing about feelings he remembers having, rather than narrating as present emotion. "Angel from Montgomery" and "Blue Umbrella" are great cuts that push this feeling home, not as raw as the originals, but with a melancholy that conveys the original feeling. "Fish and Whistle" is more relaxed sounding than the original; "Souvenirs" is less bitter. It's great fun to compare these versions to the originals sonically and emotionally. Deep down, Mr. Prine's voice sneeks in more retrospective acceptance or contentment on these versions. I feel like he is singing from some place that does have a happy (or graceful)ending, that's the greatest feeling of all on this disc. All John Prine fans must purchase, savor, and compare. Any other interested party should consider this a terrific 'Introduction to John Prine': purchase, listen, learn, then explore the originals as well. It is not very often that we get a chance to see how such an essential artist reapproaches so many hallmark songs and bends them ever so slightly, I should age so gracefully. Very enjoyable and highly recommended."
A good introduction or a wonderful review
Rob Damm | 11/08/2000
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Listening to these pristine recordings, reveling in the near-reference quality sonics, somthing occurred to me: John Prine is one of the greatest songwriters. Ever. On par with Dylan, Van Zandt... whoever. This set stongly makes this case. Sure, it took him 30 years to assemble this batch of songs, and one could regard it as a mere "Best Of", but hearing all of Prine's best material in a coherent package really brings home the point that Prine has few equals. His compostions combine humor with heartbreak to great effect. I dare you to listen to "Hello in There" and not get a lump in your throat. His delivery and phrasing, tempered by wisdom, his voice tempered by a bout with cancer, bring these haunting tales to life with all the nuance and absurdity that is the human experience. The arrangements are simple and sympathetic, allowing the songs to do the work. And great work they do. For those unfamillar with Prine, this a great introduction to his weird worldview. For veterans, think of this as the Prine disc you'll pull out and play for newbies, but also listen to more than a few times yourself. It's a good a record, and a great sort of thesis statement arguing for Prine's place alongside the great songwriters of the last half-century. *Note that the listing on this website incorrectly lists the track order. The title track is the 1st song, not "Fish and Whistle""
Outstanding
James Carragher | New York | 04/18/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Here's a CD both for Prine fans and for the uninitiated. For fans you get fifteen of his finest songs recorded anew in quiet, almost acoustic arrangements that only enhance the intimate stories he tells of misfit lovers, forgotten seniors and broken war vets. For people who've been missing out on Prine all these thirty odd years, Souvenirs is a perfect introduction and incentive to dive more fully into a great observer and teller of human stories. Best: Souvenirs, Angel from Montgomery, Donald and Lydia, and Grandpa Was a Carpenter. But on this CD the best is only slightly better than the excellent rest."