"Volume 6 is primarily Josef Hofmann's Casimir Hall Recital of 1938, featuring the Beethoven "Waldstein" Sonata and the Schumann Kreisleriana (slightly abridged), plus some shorter pieces. It also includes a complete recording of the Beethoven Moonlight Sonata from 1936 and a complete recording of a broadcast of the Beethoven G major Concerto from 1941. This pair of CD's needs a little caution -- Hofmann was in a strange mood for the Casimir Hall Recital, since he had been fired as director of the Curtis Institute shortly before the recital and his mood is, well, strange. But much of the playing is still wonderful. My assumption is that anyone interested in Hofmann will start by getting Volumes 1 & 2 -- the Chopin Concertos and the 1937 Golden Jubilee Recital. Beyond that, in choosing among Volumes 3 to 6, Volume 6 offers some unusual repertoire for Hoffman. The Waldstein is both astonishing and quirky, a performance you have to hear to believe, not that you will necessarily like it. The tempos in the second and third movement are far faster than anyone else has attempted. The melodic line and the tempos are sometimes distorted beyond recognition. But it's still amazing! In the Chopin Minute Waltz, the repeat is taken in thirds! For piano aficionados and Hofmann lovers, this is a "must" recording. For others, it is good but ranks below Volumes 4 or 5, due to problems in the Casimir Hall portion -- the quirkiness at times and the sound level that fluctuates. An excellent 32 page booklet is included."
Yo yo foo's! Hofmann be the bomb KABLAMM!
John Atherton | 12/05/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Rachmaninov considered Hofmann to be the greatest pianist he had ever seen, and these recordings are to show. Reviewing Rachmaninov's recordings of Chopin, as far as precision and skill, Hofmann kills Sergei. Every note exploads with this individual sensation of sound that only Hofmann can emit. The musical ideas are genuine. Give a listen to his original performance of Chopin's minute waltz. It's unlike anything you've ever heard. For this pianist's small fingers, he sure does have the advantage over the other greats in pounding out immaculate works from his customized Steinway & Sons."
Astonishing Performances Not to be Missed.
Bob Smith | San Francisco, CA USA | 04/02/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Want to know why Hofmann was considered to be one of the greatest titans of the keyboard? Well, let's forget nicey-nice performances, drop our scores, widen our emotional dynamic ranges, open our hearts and minds and really listen to his performance of the Chopin f minor Ballade! It is incredibly personal, passionate, and shattering! There is nothing like it, yet there there is so much more on this set to learn from and be moved by. Here is astounding pianism and musicianship from one of the greatest pianists of all time recorded live, close to his prime. Ward Marston has done wonders with the sound."
Listening to hofmann's Beethoven.
utenalover | Seoul Korea (South) | 02/05/2002
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Well, this album contains many beethoven works played by hofmann and that's interesting because it's hard to find in other series. But the result is not so satisfying. The touch is too light in Concerto, and tempo is too fast in Waldstein. Chopin works are beautifully played, but many of those can be found in other discs. In my opinion Ballade No. 4 is an ideal performance. Only Corot's recording can stand next to hof. Recommand to Hofmann fans or Chopin manias."