Enticing Music from the "Back to Bach" Movement
M. C. Passarella | Lawrenceville, GA | 04/18/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"The Gramophone reviewer quoted on this page has pretty much hit the nail on the head in the description of these neoclassical pieces and in Hogwood's delivery of them. Of the three works included here, the almost-unknown Malipiero's Ricercari is the most seriously intentioned. Also, surprisingly, given that Stravinsky just about singlehandedly invented musical modernism, the Ricercar is most modernist of the bunch.
Casella's little confection is the prettiest of the three, with some nice contributions from a busy percussion section, including piano. (And, given that Scarlatti wrote for the Spanish court, Casella rightly includes castinets in one section of his Scarlattiana.) It is also the most episodic, without the constructional glue that Stravinsky and Malipiero found to hold their works together. Ultimately, Scarlattiana is a bit vapid for all its attractiveness. You may not return to it as often as to the other pieces, but it is fun to hear nonetheless.
While you might already have Stravinsky's famous work in your collection, Hogwood's performance, with a fine contribution from tenor Anthony Spiri in the brief vocal numbers, is about as good as I've heard--lots of forward momentum, lots of color from the fine chamber orchestra. Also, the Arte Nova engineers provide a recording that is very present without being hard edged or overbearing; there is a nice sense of ambience as well.
So for an introduction to a mostly forgotten composer who has something to say (Malipiero) or for a state-of-art performance of a lesser masterwork by a twentieth-century master (Stravinsky), this is an attractive package. Arte Nova's low price, as always, is a nice incentive to collectors as well. Enjoy."
Christopher Hogwood Klassizistische Moderne Volume3
George M. Tenegal | Chicago, Illinois | 02/22/2008
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I was so happy to find a recording of Casella's Scarlattiana. It is a wonderfully inventive and charming work, which deserves to be much more well known. The performance is excellent! The other works on the CD by Stravinsky and Malipiero make for a wonderful program."
Don't just sit there, grab it!
William Dodd | Castle Rock, WA USA | 08/04/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"You may not fine this review very deep--- just know that you have the best in approachable modern music conducted by one of the best "classical" conductors. At this price, buy many and treat your friends! Absolutely first rate, and recommended without reservation."