Suave readings but too calculated
John Weretka | Melbourne, Australia | 06/20/2002
(3 out of 5 stars)
"I found this most recent performance of the music for the wedding of Ferdinando de Medici and Christine de Lorraine interesting to compare to the much older recording with Emma Kirkby, Emily van Evera, the Taverner Consort et al (1988). There is absolutely no doubt that the current recording develops many of the themes which the older recording glosses over, including beauty of sound. There is much beautiful singing on the current recording, including an extremely convincing reading of the song of Arion by Stephan Macleod (although Nigel Rogers' singing of this on the 1988 recording is one of the major reasons to own that recording). The major difference between this new recording and the 1988 recording is the understanding of scale -- the old recording conceptualises this is as a large, magnificent series of tableaux while the newer recording very rarely has everyone singing or playing together. For my money, the instrumentation of the old recording is much more varied and colourful as well. Despite the occasionally very ugly vocal sounds and the relatively colourless though nimble singing of Emma Kirbky, the 1988 recording really captures the energy and magnificence of the music. The new recording is just too calculated and light-limbed."