The four stars are for the performance, not the music
J Scott Morrison | Middlebury VT, USA | 01/02/2003
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I'd heard of Leo Ornstein as long ago as the 1950s. I knew he had been an avant garde composer and an activist/publicist for it and for advanced composers way back in the 1920s. I knew that he lived to be more than 100 years old. I knew that he'd been described as a 'Futurist'. But I'd never heard a note of his music. And since I buy everything that Marc-André Hamelin records, I bought this one. I've tried, I've really tried, to get inside the music. But so help me I can't. It does have a certain descriptive quality that works; the 'Suicide in an Airplane', for instance, does indeed go into a tailspin and crash. But for the life of me I can't see the purpose of this brutal style of composition; it makes Ives at his most discordant sound like a pantywaist. I will doff my hat to Hamelin for taking it on, and I'll bet these are the best performances these pieces are likely to receive any time soon, and surely if anyone could make a listener accept the music, Hamelin could. But not me. I'm willing to chalk it up to my own deficiencies. Be warned, this is not easy music. It is not pretty music. It often sounds like someone banging out his impression of chinoiserie, or a plane crash, or some wild men dancing in an abandoned manner. Not for the unadventurous."
One of the best classical CDs I have ever heard
05/23/2003
(5 out of 5 stars)
"It is shameful that Ornstein sank into obscurity after a brief period of fame early in the century. His music is simply magnificent, especially the piano quintet, but his solo piano music is so stunning, that it is hard to find the right adjective. Anyone who loves modern classical music should buy this. It is one of the greatest collections of piano composition I have ever heard. Ditto for the Janice Weber piano collection on Naxos, and check out the piano quintet too! Ornstein's works have not been widely performed and recorded, so keep eyes peeled. His hammering, forceful piano concerto needs to be recorded also. Perhaps Hamelin will pick that one up as well."