"I will admit it--when I first heard this album, I couldn't help but wonder exactly what I'd got myself into, or even whether I was going to like the thing. It sure had some neat stuff, that I could tell, but other things were very quirky, highly unusual, and perhaps a bit dated on the first hearing. But over time, I came to appreciate this album, and now I rate it quite highly indeed. I initially heard of it thanks to a recommendation by Pink Floyd's keyboardist Richard Wright, in a 1996 interview given to Record Collector Magazine.
Mr. Wright (who incidentally also thinks highly of Remain in Light) describes his first reaction to the album, presumably on its initial release: "This knocked me sideways when I first heard it--full of drum loops, samples and soundscapes, stuff that we really take for granted now, but which was unheard of in all but the most progressive musical circles at the time." That's really the key to getting used to this album--remembering that these were the first ventures into things we now consider ordinary. In a certain way, the roughness of parts of it gives it a unique sound that sets it far apart from the overpolished works of today. That is not to say this is *sloppy* in any way--the best was done with the technology that existed then, and for that I respect David Byrne and Brian Eno."There's a song called The Jezebel Spirit where there's a snippet of a preacher and the way the sounds were mixed in was so fresh it was amazing," Mr. Wright comments on a track that seems to get good reviews from most people. While I admit the track is well put together, there are times when I skip it because it can be quite unnerving! If you ask me, that exorcist sounds much more evil at times than the supposed demon he is trying to remove! I'm afraid I can't see why some reviewers are calling this track optimistic. Probably, in addition to "The Jezebel Spirit", my least listened-to track on this album is "Moonlight in Glory". However, over time, I have actually come to appreciate it even if it's not a favorite; this is why I no longer feel any heartburn with giving a full 5-star rating.In my opinion, the three strongest tracks are the ones that draw from Middle Eastern sources for their vocals. Each of them, including the painfully short "A Secret Life", I wish had been longer! My two favorites were those with vocals sampled from Lebanese mountain singer Dunya Yusin: "The Carrier" and "Regiment". I must also point out the excellent guitar work in "Regiment", which seems to me like a precursor to the similarly enjoyable work in Speaking in Tongues' "Making Flippy-Floppy". I also noticed what seemed to be almost a sort of commentary by David Byrne upon politicians and televangelists (the latter are not slams on religion, in my opinion--rather, the *popularization* of it); the way sound clips are used seem to make both groups look a bit ridiculous at times. For instance, "Mea Culpa's" juxtaposition of the babbling politician's weasling out of whatever he did with David Byrne's listless "blah blah blah blah" makes just as much of a statement as if he'd written lyrics of that nature and sang them. I also notice that in the song "Come With Us", he makes the evangelist sound rather like some freaky cultist, which in my opinion sometimes becomes the case when the evangelist focuses upon creation of a personality cult rather than a religious organization. There are other examples than just these two, however.Overall, I think this is a very worthwhile album if you're willing to put forth the effort that may be needed to adjust to it."
Une décennie d'avance
Stargrazer | 08/02/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Un bijou! Une fusion techno-ambiant largement en avance sur son temps. L'exploration des possibilités du "sampling" par Byrne-Eno est prodigieuse et sert l'oeuvre, non pas comme simple artifice, mais comme véritable instrument de base..."
(missing track) One of the Best Albums
perseus69 | San Jose, CA United States | 08/09/2003
(5 out of 5 stars)
"there was an earlier version with the track "Qu'ran" on it, but they had to cut it from later editions due to political/PR pressures.this is one of the very best Brian Eno albums, an artist whose best works tend to be collaborations anyway (i.e, Bowie, Talking Heads, etc.). an early (though not first) example of certain types of sampling (vocal) mixed with live instruments and loops. david byrne (talking heads) apparently played most of the wide variety of acoustic instruments used to make the sounds that weren't sampled off the radio or an old record. such sound sources reportedly included a pot, a spoon, a box, and other unusual items (no doubt "treated" or manipulated somehow by Eno to sound totally different). the sampled voices are great, including berkley radio personality Charles Amirkhanian, some famous female arabic singer (sorry, forgot who ;), a great gospel preacher, and various other radio personalities.Byrne and Eno work very well together on this album to balance out each others worst tendencies and enhance their better ones, imho. this could very well be the best album released by both of these very prolific artists-both of whom have released a lot of great albums."
Essential
Stargrazer | deep in the heart of Michigan | 11/07/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This Dutch import is available domestically for a lot less than $21. I picked it up new at my local record store for $13. Do a little searching off-site, I'm sure you can find it for less.
An absolutely amazing, seminal piece of sample-based composition, full of voices from fire-and-brimstone preachers to contrite politicians to disturbing exorcisms. All this is layered into a bed of funk and world-beat polyrhythms that is astonishing to behold."