Good song, good dubs!
03/11/2004
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I usually don't like dub mixes but these are great and I find myself pushing the repeat button. The Calderone vocal remixes are not on this but I still think this single is a must have for the dubs, and of course for the EXCELLENT original version which Madonna didn't ruin at all despite all the critics. Madonna's version is extremly well done at my opinion with vocal & musical arrangements which are a pure delight to listen to.
True, the two dubs are almost identical and I don't see the point... On the first one the repeated vocal part is "this will be the day that I (die)", while a few more vocal parts from the chorus are added to the next one (two times).
This cd is actually the UK part 1 cd-single."
Pretty good...
06/15/2000
(3 out of 5 stars)
"Madonna's version of American Pie can be labelled boring, but the two dance versions on here at least offer some variety. The extended remix is a mind-numbing trance offering, good for a club. Definitely not her best dance work, but far from the worst."