Brilliant recital
operalover | Australia | 03/02/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This is an amazing CD of schubert lied- if only it wasn't in such short measures. Recorded in 1981- this recording showcases price at her idiomatic best; predating her isolde recording with carlos kleiber. The recording is of premium quality, the accompanist wonderfully sensitive and now a comment on the performance. The selection is rather secure and really stays in the popular stream for song choice but the voice, the interpretation is breathtaking. Price has a unique coolness to her singing- sometimes criticised for being so but here in this recital it couldn't have been more appreciated. The legato, the tone, the wonderful diction and the incredible warmth of her singing pits her in the league of schwarzkopf and janowitz and indeed she outshines her in some regards. 'Der hirt auf dem felsen' is extraordinarily moving but vocally it is less secure than her recording with James Lockhart but still wonderful. Lied singing cannot get any better than this most cherishable of schubert recitals."
An outstanding recital by a major Schubertian, at her best.
e.j.powell@admin.abdn.ac.uk | Scotland | 08/07/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Dame Margaret Price has an enviable reputation for the beauty of her voice, for the 'aristocratic' quality of her lieder singing, and above all, her Schubert. Despite the recent decline in her vocal abilities, this cd catches her at her mature best - tone, interpretation and communication are wonderful -- as is the accompanist, Sawallisch, no less. Very highly recommended. A wonderful testament to a disappearing generation of recitalists."