Mariah Gets a Second Chance
Running in Place | 09/12/2009
(4 out of 5 stars)
"By the time 2005 rolled around, Mariah Carey was considered a has-been. But as soon as "We Belong Together" topped the charts - and held on for 14 weeks - her Glitter days were long-forgotten. That single was a perfect combination of Mariah's big ballad past and hip-hop present, with its heavy bass line and a grand finale of her trademark belting. It also notably references old school slow jams from Babyface and Bobby Womack. That old school style is present throughout The Emancipation of Mimi, and it's the main ingredient in this enjoyable collection. Big Jim Wright assists on "I Wish You Knew" and "Circles," tracks that recall Diana Ross - with added runs and high notes, of course. "Mine Again" is a big-voiced plea for a second chance that ranks among Mariah's most soulful and believable songs. Most of the hip-hop numbers are infectious, like the summery "Say Somethin," with a classic Snoop verse, and "Get Your Number," featuring a chorus from JD (who oddly sounds just like Nelly). Ironically, her collaboration with Nelly himself, "To the Floor," is underwhelming and forgettable. Some of the songs do run together, but this is ultimately one of Mariah's finest and most consistent albums. Several years of unimpressive sales made this return to form that much sweeter. It was great to hear her finally sing with her full voice and look to the past for inspiration. 4 Stars.
"Don't Forget About Us" and an excellent hip-hop remix of "We Belong Together" are great additions to this re-release."