Search - Mostly Autumn :: Pink Floyd Revisited

This should be in Mostly Autumn Catalogue

Robbybob | Jesup, GA. USA | 11/20/2005

(5 out of 5 stars)

"First of All - As the previous reviewer said - this is NOT PINK FLOYD - but it is still a great DVD.

Hopefully, Amazon will transfer this title into the Mostly Autumn section, as it has nothing to do with Pink Floyd except that "a really great band" is attempting to play (and not too shabbily in my opinion) some Pink Floyd songs.

The person who reviewed this and found out it was not Pink Floyd, and then refused to listen to it is, in my opinion, very sad, as they are missing out on discovering a great new band - at least they should listen to the other DVD that features Mostly Autumn's back catalogue.

I like the idea of the previous reviewer who split his stars over both discs, so I am going with a 4 for the Pink Floyd disc - because it is not Pink Floyd, and secondly I felt that Heather Finley was not kept busy enough singing - she has a beautiful voice, and I think she would have made it better if she had sung more (maybe Pink Floyd purists might not agree, but they probably wouldn't buy this album anyway - which is a shame, as they are right up there with them in great music) and not stood at the back of the stage looking lost. For the Mostly Autumn back catalogue disc I give them 6 stars - Remember though I am biased because I just love Mostly Autumn's music.

IF you have this album thinking it is Pink Floyd - play the second DVD - I can reccomend all the songs, but in particular Evergreen, Heroes Never Die, Mother Nature, Never the Rainbow and Passengers are outstanding songs in their own right.



IF YOU LIKE PINK FLOYD - buy some Mostly Autumn (Not necessarily this DVD) I would strongly reccomend you start out with The Next Chapter.

Trying to describe MA music is not easy (and comparisions with PF are easy to make) their music starts of slowly, and builds into some great rock - with some awesome guitar playing by Bryan Josh. If you like interesting and differenc rock music you WILL like Mostly Autumn.



To sum up, I hope this album gets moved into the Mostly Autumn section and I hope that Pink Floyd fans (of which I am one of them) give this band a chance, and not just rate them one star without listening to them. I don't think it is the band's fault that they have been caught up in this, I can't blame them for wanting to perform PF songs after the Richard Wright interview - they have been around a while and obvioulsy want to increase their fan base. MOSTLY AUTUMN PLAY GREAT MUSIC - GIVE THEM A LISTEN - You will be very glad you did."

No, This is not Pink Floyd...It's Mostly Autumn

Music4al | Toronto, Canada | 06/05/2005

(4 out of 5 stars)

"One of the reviews said that this DVD was sold to him as Pink Floyd...If you read the DVD carefully you would have easily discovered that it was Mostly Autumn playing....First clues...The big picture on the front shows Mostly Autumn not Pink Floyd... In future, Stop dealing with disreputable or unknowlegeble record stores....especially if the clerks are decades younger than the music your looking for. I went to buy this because it was Mostly Autumn, and the clerk told me it was not Pink Floyd, I told him that I knew it was Mostly Autumn, but complimented him on his knowledge and helpfulness. Now onto the performance, The Pink Floyd side DVD 1, this is a obviously an attempt at a cover band doing there best to play Pink Floyd but not to totally do it so it sounds like a Memorex copy, they put in their own stylings while keeping true to the songs structure and feel, overall I rate the performance about 3 1/2 out of five. The second disc of their own material DVD 2 is where the band shines, because it is they're own tunes they seem more relaxed and confortable that the performance comes together and is really quite good. I would rate it a 4 1/2 out of five... so the rating is middle ground of 4 out of 5 stars."

??????......????? What's the....

Dussausaye Philippe | france | 08/19/2006

(4 out of 5 stars)

"I do not understand one of the review (Lance's) giving one star, and saying that he didn't watch the DVD....How can you give a note without even watching the show? I saw MA in concert in France, I have most of their albums and concerts and I really think that it's a fabulous band. I recommand it expressivly to anyone who loves progressive rock, celtic music and great music played with deep feelings like Floyd off course also RPWL, MARILLION, and more and more..."