A refined interpretation
Dahirel Edmée | Saint-Brieuc,France | 06/22/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This recording is all we can wait from an artist like Brendel: intellectual but emotional, not revolutionary but not old-fashionned .With the high complicity of Charles Mackerras, he tells us a sort of story, describing the dark feelings the composer used to have ( Those are his two unique piano concerti in mineur mode ) .Playing his own cadenzas , the pianist shows his way of singing these episodes , using a sublime sonority ( very well reported) ,dialoging with the orchestra, always changing of atmosphere .The art of Brendel goes from the subtility of the nuances to the balance, he instaures .The works are sublime and as dramatic as if they were instrumental operas. Later composers like Beethoven strongly admire them. This disc transmits us their humanity, sounding as Mozart should have wanted. passionate."
Brendel's latest is as good as his classic from the '70's
John Kwok | New York, NY USA | 05/02/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I think I can understand why Brendel decided to record these two concerti again. He's a cerebral pianist who appears interested in taking a fresh look at familiar works. Apparently, he was satisfied that he had given his best performances in nearly all of Mozart's piano concerti in his classic 1970's Philips recordings with Neville Marriner and the Academy of Saint Martin in the Fields, but decided that there was room for improvement with these, the only concerti in minor keys. However, I don't really notice much difference in his performances in the latest and earlier Philips recordings. Perhaps his playing is now a bit more refined, and maybe he does play with a bit more forte than necessary, but his technique and tempi are virtually unchanged. Sir Charles Mackerras' conducting is a bit more dramatic than Sir Neville Marriner's, yet Mackerras remains a subtle, sympathetic accompanist for Brendel. And yes, the Scottish Chamber Orchestra does sound a bit "beefy" in its performance, but this might be due to state of the art recording technology. Those interested in great performances of these Mozart piano concerti should be delighted with either version with Brendel as soloist."