PHIL Y. from CENTERVILLE, OH Reviewed on 10/18/2009...
I always considered "White City" to be Pete Townshend's best solo album. It's the perfect blend of hard rock songs to ballads and Pete does them equally well. He has great musicians backing him up, too, which makes all the difference!
CD Reviews
His last Top 40 album
Anyechka | Rensselaer, NY United States | 08/02/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This album came out in November of 1985 (a month before my sixth birthday), and was the last Top 40 album Pete put out, as well as the last Top 40 album by any of the remaining three former members of The Who. The third track, "Face the Face," was also the last hit single by any of them; it reached #26 in America, the same position the album reached on both the American and British charts. (There's also a film of this album, with some songs that weren't included on the album, but I haven't seen the film yet; the main character is named James, a grown-up version of Jimmy from 'Quadrophenia.') Though it's billed as a novel, which might seem pretentious to some people, and has a very Eighties (i.e., overproduced) sound to it, it's very tight and consistent. It's also a concept album, about a middle-aged man having some difficulties in life coming home to the place he grew up and feeling disillusioned by what has happened to the place in spite of good childhood memories, and concept albums just aren't considered hip anymore.
My faves on here are "Face the Face" (so loud, thumping, and energetic, particularly the long and tense build-up in the beginning), "Give Blood" (which also has an amazing musical build-up before the lyrics begin), "Brilliant Blues" (the only song on here where he uses his trademark high notes; it shows he takes care of his voice instead of constantly showing off with a tenor/low-range falsetto just because he can), "Crashing by Design," "White City Fighting" (co-written with David Gilmour), and the closing track, "Come to Mama" (which has a beautiful sweeping flourish of instrumentation as it winds down towards the end). This is an album that shows how to celebrate middle age and turning forty musically properly. Instead of still singing about the same old things or writing about lusting after hot women, he's writing and reflecting on getting older, becoming disillusioned with the place he came from, not being so young anymore, and dealing with romantic rejections. Too bad more artists can't write mature albums like this when they get older instead of living in the past and still writing the kind of songs they did when they were in their twenties."
A Masterpiece - Don't buy it if...
Another Floyd | The LeftCoast: Occupied California | 01/01/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This CD is a masterpiece. Don't buy it... if you want more Who music. I'm not even sure it's rock. The music - or "novel" as it's subtitled -- defies genre. (Liner notes state that White City is a film written by Pete Townshend.) Townshend always refused to be confined by traditional rock music format, as demonstrated by his fondness for "rock operas," and quirky Who songs.The whole of it is a fine composition, with tracks linked lyrically and musically. It's best listened to in its entirety. With each listen you'll hear something new. (I can say this even after having worn out a cassette of same.) Townshend layers the music, and fills many "unused spaces" with surprising sounds (in a much more disciplined way than, say, Beck). He uses vast and unusual combinations of instruments, such as the harmonica and horns in "Face the Face." He uses repetition, and strings the listener through 2-minute intros. Lyrics contain their own layers of meaning and word craft that come to light over time.This "album" elevates Townshend to a level of compositional artistry that most musicians will never see... largely because they don't even know it's there."
"Misunderstood"
K. Manzel | Falls Church, VA United States | 05/16/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I'm confused by people who say this album is not as good as "Rough Mix" or "Empty Glass," especially "Who Came First." This is an artist at his sober, clarified, focused best. When you listen to this aurally intoxicating album, you are hearing an artist who's created an album with every note, every effect, every intonation exactly as he intended it to sound. I listened to "White City" once or twice about ten years ago, and just again picked it up a month ago. I think I was too young to appreciate its layered complexity. I can't stop playing it, and I have--and enjoy--all the albums mentioned above. "Crashing by Design" is such a singular lyrical and musical gem that it takes probably 10 listens before even catching all the meaning, let alone the multiple dimensions of space he explores with the sound. What a pity, Townshend was so crushed by the critical and public disappointment in this album that he never plays even a single cut from it live. That may be the most telling aspect of the passion he poured into "White City." Please give it a listen."
A hidden masterpiece
Roy R. Geurts | 09/10/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Very simple not a weak song on the album. The 80's were a vapid silly time for rnr but this album somehow transcends time. Great lyrics and fantastic musicianship. Buy This Now!"