Durchaus Phantastisch End Leidenschaftlich Vorzutragen - Im Legendenton - Erstes Tempo
Massig. Durchaus Energisch - Etwas Langsamer - Viel Bewegter
Langsam Getragen. Durchweg Leise Zu Halten - Etwas Bewegter
Albumblatt I: Ziemlich Langsam
Albumblatt II: Schnell
Albumblatt III: Ziemlich Langsam, Sehr Gesangvoll
Albumblatt IV: Sehr Langsam
Albumblatt V: Langsam
Leicht Und Zart - Minore I. Etwas Langsamer - Minore II. Etwas Langsamer - Zum Schluss. Langsam
Mikhail Pletnev is a phenomenal pianist. His technique is truly stunning and as effortless as brushing a feather-duster across the keyboard. His tone is beguilingly beautiful, smooth as silk and velvet; he seems to caress ... more »the keys, coaxing from them entire layers of sonorities and an endless variety of colors, nuances and dynamics. Gold Medalist at the Tchaikovsky Piano Competition, his repertoire ranges far and wide; his award-winning recordings include music by Scarlatti, C.P.E. Bach, Grieg, Rachmaninov, Prokofiev, and, being a conductor and composer as well, his own works and transcriptions. Musically, he must be one of the most individualistic and original performers before the public. This disc shows that Schumann, the quintessential romantic, has found a kindred spirit, but one whose approach is very much his own. Pletnev does not hesitate to bring out changes of mood, dynamics and character with quite drastic shifts of tempo, heralded by big ritardandos and long pauses. Thus, his playing is extraordinarily free, yet simple, lesiurely, comfortable and without fuss. And though all the liberties are obviously carefully thought out (and might at times seem a bit excessive), they have an almost improvisatory spontaneity that gives them a feeling of being freshly experienced, as if he were making everything up on the spot. He underlines the contrasts between the variations of the Symphonic Etudes (and replaces a variation of the work's later, standard version with two from the earlier one); the Fantasie is truly fantastic, rhapsodic, heroic, passionate, deeply felt. Of the five rather unfamiliar "Album Leaves" (or Colored Leaves), four are slow and singing, one is a wispy witches' dance, and the Arabesque is all tenderness, ardor and charm. --Edith Eisler« less
Mikhail Pletnev is a phenomenal pianist. His technique is truly stunning and as effortless as brushing a feather-duster across the keyboard. His tone is beguilingly beautiful, smooth as silk and velvet; he seems to caress the keys, coaxing from them entire layers of sonorities and an endless variety of colors, nuances and dynamics. Gold Medalist at the Tchaikovsky Piano Competition, his repertoire ranges far and wide; his award-winning recordings include music by Scarlatti, C.P.E. Bach, Grieg, Rachmaninov, Prokofiev, and, being a conductor and composer as well, his own works and transcriptions. Musically, he must be one of the most individualistic and original performers before the public. This disc shows that Schumann, the quintessential romantic, has found a kindred spirit, but one whose approach is very much his own. Pletnev does not hesitate to bring out changes of mood, dynamics and character with quite drastic shifts of tempo, heralded by big ritardandos and long pauses. Thus, his playing is extraordinarily free, yet simple, lesiurely, comfortable and without fuss. And though all the liberties are obviously carefully thought out (and might at times seem a bit excessive), they have an almost improvisatory spontaneity that gives them a feeling of being freshly experienced, as if he were making everything up on the spot. He underlines the contrasts between the variations of the Symphonic Etudes (and replaces a variation of the work's later, standard version with two from the earlier one); the Fantasie is truly fantastic, rhapsodic, heroic, passionate, deeply felt. Of the five rather unfamiliar "Album Leaves" (or Colored Leaves), four are slow and singing, one is a wispy witches' dance, and the Arabesque is all tenderness, ardor and charm. --Edith Eisler
CD Reviews
The perfect Schumann
Roy U. Rojas Wahl | Teaneck, NJ United States | 09/21/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I don't know what some of the others reviewer's problems are. This is a most wonderful recording of music by the arch-romanticist. Seldomly have I heard a living (i.e. contemporary) pianist put so much of weight and colors in an interpretation of classical romantic repertoire (only exception: Mustonen in his Beethoven!).
Pletnev makes each note count, he phrases spaciously and lets the pieces breathe. Ahhh, Schumann, was my first reaction. Ahhh, Schumann, is to this very day my last reaction.
Highly recommended."
Romantic Music in the Hands of a Romantic Musician
Grady Harp | Los Angeles, CA United States | 08/18/2006
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Few pianists playing and recording these days polarize audiences the way Mikhail Pletnev does. The reasons for not appreciating his approach to Schumann, in this case, are solid academic arguments, and from some of the reviews here written there is much to learn about pianism in general.
This listener falls into the admiring category. Knowing that the Romantic pianists and composers played from the heart at times more so than the mind, Pletnev seems to fit into the heady team of the salon gatherings from the time of Schumann. His liberties taken with ritards and rubatos, with phrasing and with tempi, may sound indulgent to some, but to this listener Pletnev plays with complete charm and candor and heart on the sleeve approach without neglecting his extraordinarily impeccable musicianship and intelligence. One can nearly hear the salon ladies swoon and faint and that makes for exciting listening - if this superb recording is approached in the Romantic mindset.
Pletnev surveys the 'Symphonic Etudes', Op. 13, the Fantasie in C major, Op. 17, the much loved 'Album (Colored) Leaves', Op. 99, and the elegant 'Arabeske in C major, Op. 18. His technique is light, airy, supple, sure, and spontaneous in approach - and for this listener that is enough! Grady Harp, August 06
"
Variable
Anthony S. | Chicago, IL USA | 05/12/2004
(3 out of 5 stars)
"This isn't an album I would pay full price for, and luckily I didn't have to. Pletnev has some interesting ideas in the Symphonic Etudes, but the Fantasy is not as successful due to some questionable tempo choices--it simply drags in parts. Tone is plush as on previous DG releases, with occasionally explosive bass in the Fantasy and remarkably airy playing in its final movement. Filler pieces (Bunte Blaetter and Arabesque) are adequate but the disc is not quite satisfying as a whole. Pollini and Richter remain touchstones in these works."
The gratest of his generation.
retkels | The Netherlands | 04/02/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Pletnev is a great performer. Same as Sokolov. Pletnev is totally in balance and the best of his generation now. He is exiting, elegant,soft, romantic and of course technically perfect. And very wise. I have all his CD's and listen always to him in the Concert building in Amsterdam. I hope he will be playing Joh.Seb.Bach sometime.
I recommend his Listz performance (CD)and Carl Ph.Em. Bach CD. Both is great and perfect! Listen to him if you are a good listener and you will agree.
Margaret Kels."