The more trombones, the better
Anthony Cooper | Louisville, KY United States | 06/27/2009
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Roswell Rudd pulls together a bunch of different groups for variations on the album's theme -- trombones. He has a brass-heavy core group, and a bunch of brass-heavy guest artists as well. Sex Mob is on one song, and is the only trombone-free guest, but they're infamous for sliding their notes around.
The album begins with a short fanfare, then gets into a bunch of trombone songs. They all have a funky, New Orleans feel, and they are pretty much all good. The only song I have reservations about is "Sand In My Slide Shuffle". Sex Mob and Bonerama show up for good cameos, and Wycliffe Gordon and Joshua Roseman play on two songs. Sometimes CD's with shifting rosters sound disjointed, but on "Trombone Tribe" the rosters and songs all have enough in common that the music flows and swings. The end of the CD is a bit of a left-turn. Recorded in Africa, "A Place Above" is a five-track-long, 7-minute long suite. Based on the liner notes, Rudd tried to duplicate the spiritual ecstacy of an African church service (or services) he attended. Unfortunately, it doesn't quite get there, but it's good music, especially the modal improvisation section.
This is one of the better discs of 2009 so far. By way of comparison, I rate it higher than the 2009 releases of Joshua Redman, The Bad Plus, Dave Douglas, and Joe Lovano. It's one of the better 4-star discs, and I recommend it.
"