Search - Kupiec, Lettberg :: Schnittke: The Piano Concertos Nos. 1-3 [SACD]

Get it for the early concerto only...

villegem | canada | 11/22/2008

(3 out of 5 stars)

"3 stars for Frank Stroble's work in bringing Schnittke's film music repertoire out on a consistent basis and for unearthing the early piano concerto.

3 stars for Kupiec who does a good job in bringing this interesting score to light and is quite convincing throughout the piece. The slow movement reveals the potential Schnittke will demonstrate later on in his career. Just as the recent release of Nagasaki and Symphony O under the initiative of A. Ivashkin (BIS, see my review), it is a welcome addition to early Schnittke repertoire on disc.



However the other better known concerti are not on the same level. Kupiec is disappointing in the Concerto for Piano and Strings, so is Strobel.

As for the 4 hand piece, with Postnikova and Irina Schnittke playing it on Erato, re-released recently to boot, there is no need to look further.



So I recommend this CD for the early concerto only.

--------------



Post Scriptum:



A recent reviewer Dan Morgan from MusicWeb International wrote about the Concerto for Piano & Strings in this recording:



"The pensive opening to the single-movement Concerto for piano and string orchestra is most welcome, emerging with commendable clarity and naturalness. But it's only a temporary respite, the glowering bass and note clusters hinting at the more radical Schnittke of the 1960s. That said, there is an interior aspect to the music that comes across as surprisingly intimate. The pared-down orchestra - strings only - sounds weightier than one might expect, especially in the work's grinding unison passages. Strobel draws impassioned playing from his band, who dig into their repeated phrases with gusto.



Indeed, this is a strangely schizophrenic concerto - sample the jazzy piano and moody bass at 10:16 - that overturns conventions and expectations with astonishing facility. The curious dissonances from 13:29 onwards are a case in point, yet remarkably the composer stitches it all together very convincingly indeed. It all winds down with some wonderfully austere, lyrical playing from Kupiec and ghostly murmurings from the strings. (Wiki's entry on Schnittke refers to his `polystylistic technique'; surely polymorphic would be more accurate, as this continuously evolving score so aptly demonstrates.)"



Clearly if these are the feeling evoked by this piece for this reviewer, something was quite wrong at both ends: "pensive" opening is "quite welcome"... really? "An interior aspect to the music"? Obviously this reviewer had no clue about the work he reviewed -the minute by minute description is a convenient way to add lines to the text but says little about the work, the forces in presence and the themes developed by Schnittke- and the reference to Wikipedia seals off such a hack job and achieves to demonstrate Mr Morgan's superfical account of Schnittke's thinking."

Uneven Schnittke Concertos--Early Find, Middle Treat, Late G

C. Pontus T. | SE/Asia | 01/03/2010

(4 out of 5 stars)

"It would be something of a stretch to say that I am an admirer of Schnittke's music in general. His clashing juxtapositions of traditional diatonics and modernist dissonances--referred to by himself as 'polystylism'--often sound more disturbing than intriguing. Granted, there are those who find him to be the answer to dead-end serialism--including no less than Robert von Bahr, founder and owner of Swedish BIS, who once told me Schnittke was his favourite 20th-century composer.



Piano Concerto 'No 1' is an early work, written in 1960 when Schnittke was still searching for his own voice--in other words, in his pre-polystylistic years. The first and third movements, reminiscent of Bartók, Khachaturian, Shostakovich and even Barber, show vast talent but relatively little originality. They are both tonal--based in E minor and C minor, respectively--largely built as motoric monoliths. What makes the Concerto memorable is the second movement, containing a soaring B-minor elegy fused with an ingenious pizzicato recapitulation of the first-movement motif and extensive Cadenza. Kupiec/Strobel gave the second-ever performance of this Concerto on 5 November 2005, whereas this disc constitutes its world-premiere recording, caught a few days before at the Jesus-Christus-Kirche in Berlin. They both sound entirely convinced that this forgotten work is a real find, delivering a performance that will likely hold up well against any future competition.



Written in 1979, the Concerto for Piano and String Orchestra signifies Schnittkian polystylism (Piano Concerto 'No 2' on this disc). Simple triads revolving around C minor are juxtaposed with string glissandi, bass clusters and motoric marches. There is a splendid performance by Postnikova and the London Sinfonietta under Rozhdetsvensky from the early 1990s, which not only sounds highly idiomatic but also has tremendous energy and bite. Kupiec and RSO Berlin under Strobel take a different approach altogether, characterised by attention to detail and consummate blending of sound. Even if they benefit from superior SACD sound, they sound just a tad tame and cautious next to Postnikova/Rozhdetsvenky.



The Concerto for Piano Four Hands and Chamber Orchestra (Piano Concerto 'No 3') was written in 1988, representing the late Schnittke in declining health. It is indeed a very gloomy work with little appeal to this reviewer. Regrettably, most of the polystylism has elapsed into aleatory noise. Kupiec and Strobel, joined by Lettberg, sound technical and accurate, but Postnikova/Schnittke/Rozhdetsvenky, who premiered the Concerto in 1990, make more music out of the depressive score.



To sum up, I agree with fellow reviewer, villegem, that the chief motivation for acquiring this disc--apart from the demonstration-worthy SACD sound--is the 'First' Concerto, whose quality far supersedes its 45-year absence from the concert hall. Even if it may not be nearly as great as the famous warhorses of the first half of the 20th century, it is as good as any Piano Concerto emerging from its second half. The 'Second' Concerto is a polystylistic treat--as good as anything that has come from Schnittke's pen. Kupiec/Strobel offer a well-conceived alternative to Postnikova/Rozhdetsvenky's rock-'n'-roll performance. As to the 'Third' Concerto, I remain more or less indifferent.



REFERENCES: 'First' Concerto--This One; 'Second' Concerto--Postnikova/Rozhdetsvenky"