Reverend_Maynard | Glasgow, United Kingdom | 12/17/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This may well be one of the most unpleasant albums I have ever heard. Not that the music is atrocious or the singing is annoying, rather that the records unfailingly bleak outlook on humanity and the inclusion of some truly disgusting samples and effects make this one of the ultimate uneasy listening experiences. Needless to say, I really like it.
SGM fall somewhere between the clinical, super heavy and rhythmically confrontational metal of Meshuggah, the eclecticism of Mr. Bungle, and the willfully complex and initially difficult to appreciate stylings of avant prog like Thinking Plague. Far from being a mixture of the above though, SGM moulds this (pretty diverse) set of influences into a mammoth display of instrumental prowess, schizophrenic sampling and claustrophobic production, obscure and baffling lyrics and even a little techno half song which degenerates into a Meshuggah style pounding guitar fest. I think the bands finest achievement then, flying in the face of such carefree experimentation (as an album, this is probably the epitome of anti commercialism) is that it does craft memorable songs, and even produces moments of, albeit chilly and never fully comfortable, beauty.
For instance, the first track, 'Hymn To The Morning Star', adapts the words from a TV theme, I believe, into a chilling ballad of sorts. The initial verses are delivered with a very Mike Patton esque croon, and when the chorus eventually kicks in, female vocals back up the male to very creepy effect. The song acts as an introduction to the second track, which sees the band let rip in full on metal mode. Convoluted rhythms and interlocking dynamics are the order of the day here, but it is particularly impressive to see the band incorporate winds, and an array of percussion instruments to lend the song an avant-ish edge as well. Brutal and constantly exciting, this is one of my favourite tracks. 'The Freedom' Club, the first lengthy piece, really sees SGM run the full gamut of its musical scope: a lilting, haunting initial section unfolds into a a driving rock oriented buildup, with some funny lyrics, before exploding into a full no thrash metal assault with Meshuggah dynamics and death-esque vocals. This track is exciting and inventive, but it probably plays second fiddle to the astonishing epic closer, 'Babydoctor' as the albums most ambitious track. Indeed, 'Babydoctor' might just be one of the most unsettling pieces of music yet, on an album littered with such triumphs. Strangely melodic and eerie, the song once again builds to a thrash conclusion but fleshes out the beginning stages with a far more atmospheric aesthetic and some accessible melodies. Its a fine note to draw the album to a close, the hilarious little sing along 'Cockroach' notwithstanding.
Such a marriage of metal and avant prog certainly wont appeal to everyone. I'd also warn this album is not for the squeamish, and requires repeat listens. Despite this, SGM are an extremely original and challenging band, the issues raised here are somewhat interesting and are pretty strange ground for a metal band to cover (they seem to be advocating a return to a kind of pre-industrial Edenic utopia, although the whole album is constructed in a decidedly tongue in cheek manner) and the playing and production are mind-blowing. Highly recommended to fans of this sort of thing, but bear in mind this is far out the mainstream it has grown legs and evolved into a quite different beast. Careful how you approach it."
The Adversary
stu | 03/27/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Does music get any better than this?
Of the many excellent avant rock groups making music in the Bay area, Sleepytime Gorilla Museum is the most excellent. Their first release, Grand Opening and Closing, was a virtually unknown masterpiece and, in my humble opinion, a milestone in the history of rock music. OF Natural History improves on their debut and earns SGM the exalted honor of My Favorite Band.
I am reluctant to make comparisons to describe this music. There are familiar aspects, but I can't help but feel that comparisons will only confuse. Deprived of reference, I am left with mere adjectives and we all know how inadequate these can be when trying to describe music.
I will say that this is serious music written and played by serious musicians. All aspects, harmony, rhythm, melody, and, most strikingly, timbre, are exciting and captivating. Absorbing the textures of SGM's aural palate is like tasting exotic cuisine after a lifetime of mush. I'm terrible at similes. The unconventional percussion, the vocal styling, the timbres of the guitars, along with Carla Kihlstedt's (Vocals, Violin) huge bag of virtuosic, ingenious tricks conspire to create music that is vibrant with aural color and makes me breathe faster and get goosebumps.
This is next level stuff.
The libretto is dark and cerebral. It centers around the idea of an inverse evolution that works alongside the "progressive" one. As humanity evolves, it also devolves by emulating the characteristics of lower and lower life forms until it finally comes to its present state of insect-like efficiency. Interesting stuff.
"
Classical Music for a new Century
Robert Wise | 08/15/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This CD (and all of the SGM work) is a great work of classical music or a rock classic -- only time will tell.
1. Story -- It has the great and complex depth of its story line of a Wagner, Mahler or Richard Strauss.
2. Dynamics -- The push and pull of the music and the story-teller can only be compared to the great Puccini.
3. Technical skill -- The virtuosity of the musicians can be compared to a great string quarter such as the Juilliard or Italian or to a witch docktor such as Paganini.
4. Philosophical -- Primitivism and futurism combined in one great elegant rant. Think Sex Pistols who were educated and were upset about the nature of reality -- not just the Queen of England and the class system.
5. Impact -- The impact of the music is liberating and requires clear and reflection to be even partially digested.
6. Sources -- They draw from heavy metal, Bartok, Berg, carnival music, Weil, etc. etc. etc.
You got it -- this is a powerhouse. I believe they are mostly classically trained. The violinist could be a reincarnation of Paganini himself.
I saw them live in Portland and they made a lasting impression of real high art -- intense beyond belief -- like watching Wagner's Ring sped up to a one hour sitting. If your mother and father like modern classical atonal music -- take them to a live show -- you will need a good set of earplugs, good scotch, and a shower after the show."
Nothing short of devastating...
Alex Whelan | San Jose, CA | 10/03/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I've listened to a lot of extreme metal bands. I can recall listening to my first Cannibal Corpse album, and thinking, "Wow, that's intense."
Then I moved up to Meshuggah, which was quite a leap. I thought, "Wow, this is intense."
And then I have come to this. This might already be some sort of cliche, but if you can picture the way the apocalypse might sound, you're still not hitting this album. Seriously, I listened to "Freedom Club", went along with the soft part with the vibe-like instruments playing, and then the math professor dream, and WHAM!!!
I'm surprised I came out alive. Mind you, these were large speakers, and I didn't expect anything that infernal to come out. Think Meshuggah with more instruments, a more demanding singer, and an overall greater burden for a listener to bear. I was in shock for about ten minutes. Well, not really, but this song in particular just made me flip.
Even before that magnum opus, there's the opening song, which has to be some sort of tongue-in-cheek stab at evangelical music, or something. I was confused, but then the lyrics to the female-male sung part clued me in. "The greatest lie ever told" and a song about "the infant God" usually don't go together. But, surely enough, they do here. Great background harmonies, by the way.
"Phthisis" is another thing completely. The female vocals are absolutely amazing, in that they convey tons of emotion. One of the things I noticed about this album is that the lyrics are genius, something that doesn't stop on any one song. But the vocals on this song always make shivers go up my spine. They're not scary, they're just aurally arresting.
Oh, and don't let me forget "Babydoctor", which could be even more intense than "Freedom Club" plus all the other songs. If one song could define a band's career, it would be this one. Agonizingly brutal vocals, without all the cookie-monster/Dani Filth scream [...]. The guy sounds like he needs therapy. But, given the album's message, the assault might be necessary to implant an idea into one's head. Just a theory.
So, all ends with the twisted kid song parody "Cockroach", and then there's a hidden track that is basically just ambience. But you've made it through the abyss. The word harsh takes on a whole new meaning on this album.
Don't expect other types of intensity. There's no black metal, no gore metal, no stereotypical death metal, no stereotypical thrash. It's completely in its own little world. For instance, most percussion on this album was hand made from things like kitchen utensils and trash cans and other common "non-instruments". Who else does that? I can't think of any other metal band that uses homemade percussion.
It's not death metal. It's not really anything that's been documented previously. If it's not your favorite, you're eventually going to admit it was at least a memorable experience. Trust me, if you dig Bungle or Thinking Plague, you'll go apes**t after hearing this.
AWESOMELY AWESOME TOTALLY RECOMMENDED FOR FANS OF: Meshuggah, Mr. Bungle (or other non-FNM Patton metal projects), Thinking Plague, Rock-In-Opposition, Frank Zappa (although that's almost a stretch, almost)"
A Small Step Backwards
Professor Z | Winnipeg, MB Canada | 02/16/2005
(4 out of 5 stars)
"SGM give us the follow-up album to their astonishing debut "Grand Opening and Closing". If I could award 10 stars out of 5 to "Grand Opening and Closing" I'd have no problem awarding 5 out of 5 to "Of Natural History". Seems to me, though, that their musical focus and daring has slipped somewhat on this one despite the fact that the lyrics project a stronger philosophical focus - rampant technology and its eroding impact on our lives. Their first album consistently sends chills up my spine even after repeated listenings. The themes are more personal and inward looking, from the disturbing rant against sleep and adulthood (Sleep is Wrong) to the even more powerful and disturbing rumination on dying and indomitable spirit (Sleepytime: Spirit is a Bone). In this latest effort we have a consistent political theme based somewhat loosely on the ideas of Ted Kosinski. Whereas the 1st album was an awe-inspiring step forward musically (with evolutionary links to one of my all time favorite avant works: King Crimson's 1973 "Lark's Tongues in Aspic"), the 2nd album seems to take a step backwards to the looser theatrical stylings of Idiot Flesh, SGM's previous incarnation. The new album does have its moments. This time, Carla Kihlstedt seems to have provided the more focused songs (although the songs are apparently extensively reworked and refined by the group as a whole) but Nils Frykdahl's voice and writing can still terrify. All in all, "Of Natural History" is extremely good and I listen to it repeatedly, but "Grand Opening and Closing" makes my desert island selection. Buy them both and check out Idiot Flesh "The Nothing Show" (available at the SGM website)."