J. C Clark | Overland Park, KS United States | 04/08/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This is the only performance of the Gounod mass I know. Had it on LP years ago, bought the CD, and it is better than I remember. An old recording, but lovely transfer and delectable sound. Gounod is a sadly underappreciated composer; the guy could write a memorable tune, and in this mass he wrote several. This works as religious and as choral music. A stirring Credo, a galvanizing Kyrie, and a glorious Agnus Dei are just some of the highlights. This is a massive, important work, lovingly performed by a clearly attentive team. The soloists shine, the orchestra is great. And considering the bargain cost and the great pairing--quite a change of pace but a scrumptious little piece--this is a delightful disc that will get a lot of use in your CD player."
THE best recording of Gounod's Messe Solennelle de Sainte Ce
Jay Young | Austin, TX USA | 11/19/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Gounod's "Messe Solennelle de Saint Cecile" was one of the last masses of the Romantic era that was actually used in a liturgical setting for a time, and probably the best. Most romantic-era masses were simply written for the concert hall- Beethoven's Missa Solemnis comes to mind. Gounod's great work is an exception, and this is the best recording of it. Though it was recorded in the 1950s, it has been preserved and restored admirably. Furthermore, the soloists in "Gloria" and "Sanctus" reach just the right balance between the lyrical and operatic sound that the music requires. In every other recording I've heard, the soloists either sing it in the syle of an art song or an opera aria, neither which does the music justice. Highly recommended."
Still The Best Recording of this work!
A. Craig | Grand Junction,CO | 06/17/2003
(5 out of 5 stars)
"EMI has done me and many others a great favor by re-issuing this
recording of Gounod's Messe Solonnelle de Sainte Cecile on CD
in their Encore series. This is the second time this recording has been issued on CD the first was in their Studio series. Frankly this recording makes the digital recording by Georges Pretre also made by EMI as an attempt to replace this one in the catalog pale into complete insignificance by the comparison.
and having the Petite Symphony as a filler is only icing on the cake. Also the price makes this a clear first choice."
Gounod: Messe Solennelle de Sainte Cécile; Petite Symphonie
Bjorn Viberg | European Union | 07/07/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Gounod: Messe Solennelle de Sainte Cécile; Petite Symphonie for wind instruments~ Franz Crass is an astounding recoding of an incredible piece of work. The mass is magnificent and being a devout Christian at heart it verily touches my spirit in so many ways. The book-let is a not so well done but the wonderful painting on the cover is a treat indeed. I love portraits and especially art made in the 16th, 17th and 18th century which I consider to be the pinnacle of what art has accomplished so far. The little wind symphony is also a nice piece of work and whilst Gonoud is not one of my favorite composers by any means one can still acknowledge a truly gifted composers when one hears it. Highly recommended indeed."
Fine - but not the best
Ralph Moore | Bishop's Stortford, UK | 04/19/2008
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I disagree with some previous reviewers that the Pretre recording is inferior to this. For me, the ungainly, Germanically throaty tenor of Heinz Hoppe here quite spoils the elegance and delicacy of the movements he sings in and Laurence Dale is far more in style and pleasing on the ear. The pacing is broader and more majestic in the Pretre - surprising for a conductor who was too often choppy and rushed in his tempi - and the sound, while not as detailed as in the Hartemann set, is grand and spacious. Both soprano soloists are lovely but I find Hendricks' silvery, shimmering tone marginally more ethereal than that of Lorengar. (There is no doubt, however, that Crass is preferable to Lafont in the baritone part - not that the latter lets the side down.)
The couplings might decide which you go for, however; if you a complete work rather than various Gounod "bon-bons", then Barbirolli's "Petite Symphonie" will be what you want; otherwise I'd stick with the HMV compilation, which features some lovely sentimental stuff."