Four Last Song
Yung Kuang Chan | Oakland, CA U.S.A. | 11/29/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I own more than 20 Four Last Song recordings and this is one of the best. Ms. Voigt's voice is so free and radiant, not to mention her impaccable German diction. The tempo seems to be the fastest among all the recordings in the market, but I find to be absolutely perfect. In my opinion, Lucia Popp/Klaus Tennstedt, and Jessye Norman/Kurt Masur are the other two excellent recordings that everyone should have."
Less than what you might expect
Yung Kuang Chan | 07/14/1999
(2 out of 5 stars)
"What more could you ask for? The New York Philharmonic, Kurt Masur, and Deborah Voigt, and the genius of Richard Strauss! I, for one, could ask for some emotional involvment. I'm sorry to say that these otherwise illustrious performers did not seem to have their hearts in their work when this live recording was made. Miss Voigt's rightly praised voice is too monochromatic in the Four Last Songs. Masur and the NY Phil. are recorded in a fog of undetailed playing and limited dynamic range. It's too bad that such an opportunity has been wasted. I don't understand why all the wonderful details that are printed in the scores of these works can not be heard. I look at the music and hear only the voice, one prominent instrument, and the bass line in the songs. As for the tonepoems, the impression is of boredom and slick professionalism. I thought we were living at the end of the 20th century not the beginning. If you want a really, really good recording of the Four Last Songs, try the Fleming/Eshenbach/Houston recording on RCA. There is heartfelt music-making, and genuine imagination worth twice the price."
Generous vocalism
C. EGBUNIWE | West Hollywood, CA United States | 02/02/2002
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Grand gorgeous gorgeous vocalism and subtle interpretation. I think other listeners have mistaken the fussy, over-done performance of Fleming for musical intelligence (hence, tasteful singers are seen as boring). Voigt finds meaning in the music instead of over-acting each word phrase. Regarding Voigt's sound, listen to early Strauss interpreters such as Ursuleac and Jeritza to get an idea of a real Strauss soprano sound - a sound that Voigt has in spadesThat said, I can't give the recording 5 stars for three reasons:1. the Norman/Masur version is the very very best2. I was present at the performances from which the recording was made and the recording does not do full justice to her voice and interpretationand2. the NY Phil's "Death and Transfiguration" is god-awful (bland, dull sounding, no sparkle, no power, no colors, NO depth, no meaning, etc.)"