The Best.
Alan Olshan | New York, NY United States | 08/24/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Of the 29 Alpines I currently own, this is the best. When a conductor makes you think that the present work is the most important piece of music ever written, it comes through -- and that's what strikes me about this performance, which I keep coming back to. I love this piece, and am intrigued by its relationship to Mahler. You can't go wrong with this recording."
Strauss in a most unusual combination ,but does it work??
P. J. Ross | uk | 03/17/2008
(4 out of 5 stars)
"This,the most unusual combination of a Finnish record company,a Czech orchestra and a Russian conductor have here combined to produce just about the best recorded performance to have appeared in years.The opportunities of the beautiful acoustics of the Czech Philharmonic's home,(the Rudolfinum in Prague),have here been used to their full advantage by the recording engineers in capturing this interpretation in sumptuous sound.
This is Ashkenazy's second attempt at this work,his first with the Cleveland Orchestra on Decca,does not really compete either as an interpretation or in terms of sound.His real challenge in this work comes from Herbert von Karajan and the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra on DGG.This combination was almost always unbeatable in the music of Richard Strauss,and so it proves here.The one thing that let it down was the sound.That has been improved in the latest "Karajan Gold" reissue,making it far more comfortable to listen to,and also making easier to appreciate what a riveting interpretation it was.It would,however, be wrong of me to give the impression that I am "damning with faint praise" this magnificent new perfomance of Ashkenazy's.It is only in comparison with Karajan that it falls slightly short.Taken on its own terms it is a winner and I recommend it highly.
"