The symphony performance is great - the overture is poor
08/29/1999
(4 out of 5 stars)
"In regards to the 3rd sypmohny: It is surprising, that at the age of 80, Karajan provides us with fire and passion and emotion erupting like it does. Not so much technical-perfection minded anymore, he concentrates on the emotion, and the result is sheer excitement. This does not, however, concern the recording of the Tragic Overture, done in 1983. The performance here is shallow, violent and unsatisfying, and the technical problems of the orchestra playing are disturbing, not to say annoying. The 1964 version of this recording of the overture ( with the Vienna Philharmonic, to found with recording company Decca ), is the best one, probably the very best ever made, an emotional volcano."