Search - Bruckner, Rattle, Birmingham So :: Symphony 7

An Unusually Intense Performance.

05/02/1999

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Despite years of composing & revising symphonies so as to make Anton Bruckner (1824-1896) more appreciated in Vienna & abroad, it was the Seventh symphony which earned this great Austrian literally an overnigh fame, internationally. The essence of Bruckner is still present in this work: catholicism, spirituality, passion, deep reflections, optimism, and the yearning for life. For the first time, Bruckner expanded the orchestral forces, including the four Wagner tubas (interchangeable with eight horns). Also, for the first time, we have witnessed the mournfulness of the Adagio, a homage to Richard Wagner who died of a heart seizure by 1883. What made this symphony an overnight success was its' maturity & depth in expressionism & feelings. The performance by the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra under Sir Simon Rattle was unusually intense & highly commited, with the tempos more broader than most of its' rival recordings. However, comparing this recording with, say, Jochum & the Staatkapelle Dresden or Herbert Von Karajan with the Vienna Phiharmonic, or Gunther Wand with the North German Radio Symphony, Rattle is not much slower, & not hopelessly so. Nevertheless, what these recordings have in common are the employment of the triangle & cymbal @ the climax of the second movement, the Adagio. The cymbal clash and triangle at the climax are still highly debated today, although seemingly, more conductors today are using them in believing that they represent what Bruckner had intended originally.Warmly recommended, with no regrets."

An Intense recording.

04/02/1999

(5 out of 5 stars)

"The Seventh symphony of Anton Bruckner (1824-1896)placed the composer on the international map after 1887. Knowing the history of this symphony in relations to Bruckner's overnight rise to fame, one rightfully would think that this work is the most performed of his symphonies. Right? Wrong, though it's a good guess. The most performed is his Fourth symphony. Nevertheless, the symphony symbolize the essence of Bruckner: catholicism, spirituality, passion, romaticism, deep reflections, optimism & the yearning for life. The performance of the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra under Sir Simon Rattle was intense & highly committed. The playing tempos on the fisrt two movements was slow, but not much slower than other fine recordings of this work (either Jochum with the Stattskapelle Dresden or Gunther Wand with the North German Radio Symphony). The recording included that highly debatable triangle & cymbal clash at the 3rd movement's climax. Recommended to the upmost."

Is there anybody else out there ...

Pater Ecstaticus | Norway | 10/18/2007

(4 out of 5 stars)

"... who appreciates this performance as highly as I do? Well, when considering such wonderful performers/artists, in the end, it all comes down to taste, but I really love this performance. (Does that tell anything about how good or bad my tastes are? ;-)

Anyhow, this recording has had its fair share of bad reviews in press, being called 'tedious' and 'lacking in human dimension' because of being too much reduced to 'architectural denominators', or imbibed with too much 'Shatneresque(?) huffing and puffing'.

Be those observations as they may, I would like to say what I like about this performance. Generally, I am not a great fan of Sir Simon Rattle, but there are a few, IMHO, wonderful exceptions. But with these exceptions, there is a lot of devided opinion as well, as expected with this conductor, who never seems to fails to 'devide the field', as it were. I do for example love Sir Simon Rattle's recording of Mahler 10 with the Berliner Philharmoniker (EMI). (Although that one is generally accepted as 'classic', I would think.) I also like his recording (more of a risk, saying this), with the same orchestra, of Mahler's 9th - even if this performance, generally not well received by press and public alike, is characterized by a lot of idiosynchrasies (While being maybe a stand-alone in the field, it does have a uniquely convincing power of its own, I believe).

The orchestral playing to my taste (and here I think anyone could agree) is mellifluous and glowingly rich in sound, from the softest pianissimos to the greatest fortissimos (probably much helped by the accoustics of the venue, the fabled Symphony Hall Birmingham). Indeed, as another (professional) reviewer has mentioned, there is a wonderful sense of architecture here, with flowing transitions between tempos. But at the same time many reviewers seem to miss a 'human side' with this performance. But I think that, generally, Anton Bruckner's music wouldn't suffer from a more 'dry-eyed' view - as opposed to Mahler's music, which could, I think, benefit from a more overtly emotional stance (but not necessarily) - and I certainly do not sense a 'lack' of anything in any department of the music making. But I do know what people mean when they say this. I do have that sensation of this 'lack of a deeper, warmer human core' with, for example, Sir Simon Rattle's Mahler 8, which indeed I don't like. (Characterized as it is by lightness of touch and emphasis on flow and trying to stress symphonic tautness, missing out a bit on the drama and the deep love sentiments that are certainly there, I believe.)

I think that any 'lack' of a 'human side' in this Bruckner 7 is compensated by glorious sound and nobility of playing. The music is taken at face value by the conductor, without any sentimentality. Very dry-eyed indeed. But no less awe-inspiring as 'musical phenomenon'. Marvelous 'architecture in sound'. To top it off, the well-balanced strings (high and low), brass and woodwind make for a wonderful, richly blended sonorous sound: nowhere is the sound 'top heavy' in one department or another. But at the same time Sir Simon Rattle and the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra find a lighter, lyrical touch that is to me very endearing, very fresh and clean.

In one sentence, there is rich sonority combined with lyrical touch and fine orchestral balance, nicely recorded. I, for one, love it. That, of course, tells everything about my own tastes (which DO allow for DIFFERENT interpretations of the same work, according to different moods and times), and nothing about what other people should think about this recording at a certain time. But please try and give it a taste, maybe you would like it as well. I could only in good conscience recommend it wholeheartedly."