Taneyev: At the Reading of a Psalm
leo marcus | Santa Monica, CA | 01/06/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This is a masterwork by an unjustly neglected composer. Perhaps the pleasures will only be discovered upon repeated hearings, but it is worth the effort.The recording is of a live concert, and the performance is not best possible, but don't wait for another."
Wonderful Music - Ghastly recording
Alasdair Brooks | Melbourne Australia | 09/29/2000
(3 out of 5 stars)
"Taneyev is - perhaps quixotically - my favourite Russian composer, and in Russia this cantata is apparently considered to be his masterpiece. On the basis of this CD, you'd never agree. While a careful listener or Taneyev fan will find much to enjoy, the recording is truly ghastly. I find the shrill sopranos particularly off-putting, and the upper registers in general remind me of fingernails on chalkboards. I'd still recommend this to people interested in this period or composer, but I can only hope that a better recording will come along soon. First-time Taneyev buyers should stick to the Oresteia overture, St. John of Damascus (both on Chandos) or the piano quintet (on Arabesque)"