"Amazon still has in stock the Opera D'Oro release of this recording. D'Oro, it seems, simply transferred the LPs to CD, rather than using the master tapes. Does anyone know if this Preiser recording suffers from the same quality issues as d'Oro's?
D'Oro's sound quality issues aside, this is probably the best Eugeny Onegin recording available. Although, whoever happens to have the 1934 (?) one with Nortsov in the title role will probably argue. As much as I enjoyed Philips release under Semyon Bychkov, it does not have the Tatiana this 1956 recordings has. The great Bolshoi soprano Galina Vishnevskaya was at the height of her powers when this studio recording was made, and man, she truly IS Tatiana, probably exactly how Tchaikovsky imagined her. Her ability to convey the appropriate age of her heroine as she transforms from a dreamy impulsive girl to wise and noble woman is a revelation. The only one, in my humble opinion, who was able to accomplish this feat is Renee Fleming (the DVD of her singing Tatiana and Dmitri Hvorostovsky singing Onegin is currently available).
On this recording, Evgeny Belov is singing the title role, and his relatively high lyric instrument is very good, but does not have the sonorous admonishing quality needed for the "sermon" scene. I particularly enjoyed Irina Archipova's Olga and Sergei Lemeshev's Lensky: these singers were of the highest caliber, portraying their characters with gorgeous singing and vivid characterization. We are very fortunate indeed to be able to hear Lemeshev singing Lensky on record, as at the time of this recording he was approaching 60 and was beginning to doubt if the powers that be would ever let him record one of his favorite roles. Boris Khaikin is a conductor of Melik-Pashaev's school -- his support of the singers is amazingly sensitive and worthy of highest praise. Anyway, the question of sound quality stands: did Preiser get a hold of the master tapes, or did it get by with a simple LP transfer?"