Great Set - But this US Edition is missing a great US 12" Ve
Bill Anthony | North Texas United States | 06/22/2006
(4 out of 5 stars)
"This stunning album was the pinnacle of 80's UK invasion pop/rock, and a great album with 4 classic singles. An extremely cool reissue, with all the b-sides and 7" versions included, and the 12" singles section of disc 2 contains Shout (and it's dub), Mothers Talk, and Head Over Heals exactly as they were released on 12" single in America, but the version of Everybody Wants To Rule The World is the Urban Mix released in the UK, not the very different and superior "Extended Version" released on 12" in the USA in March 1985. Almost perfect...."
Unnecessary and overpriced
Mike S | Alpharetta, GA United States | 10/05/2006
(2 out of 5 stars)
"The original album- 8 songs- is a five star album. I can listen to it straight through without any problem. I also don't mind the remastered edition that came out a few years ago that expanded this to 15 tracks. It has most of the same bsides/bonus tracks found here- but you can get it for half the price of this. So what do you get for the extra $15 here? 12 remixes. Big deal. I don't need to hear 4 versions of Shout in one sitting. Do yourself a favor and get the single disc of this for half the price, OR get Chonicles instead: It has the same 15 track remastered and expanded version of this album PLUS you get the expanded and remastered Hurting and Sowing the Seeds of Love CDS- 26 other (great) songs instead of 12 (boring) remixes. That's 3 expanded remastered CDs for the same price as this bloated mess."
The Best Chair Yet
David D. McFarland | Oceanside, California United States | 07/08/2006
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Well, I would have given this a full "Five" star review but as a collector of their work with everything from vinyl to CD, I can't understand WHY they put the single version of "Everybody Wants To Rule The World" when it's the same as the album version?! Anyway, they could have used the U.S.12" remix of this track instead of wasting time on the same track twice. Other then that, a great addition in which I had all the original sources and all collected together for this double CD set. I also recommend picking up the all there CD's up to "Sowing The Seeds Of Love" & the others if you really get into this band. I am also on the web which you search "Judemac Forever" on msn."
Here's what you get...
Jake | St Paul, MN United States | 07/03/2006
(4 out of 5 stars)
"When you look at this deluxe set it seems incredible the amount of material that you get--b-sides single mixes and 12" remixes. Please note that most of the b-sides offered are instrumental early versions of songs that made it on the album. Only the marauders and sea song seem up to par with the album itself. The much touted a-side is from a few years earlier and fits more closely with the hurting album. I liked the 12" remixes as primitive as they sound by todays standards, but I challenge anyone to listen to track 11 which consists of someone repeating "James Brown" close to 100 times, similar to the tom tom clubs genius of love in trying to add credibilty? to the recording. Stars are for the album itself."
Songs from the Big Chair - Enhanced
Marlon Brock | Texas | 07/12/2006
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Songs from the Big Chair, the original version, is comparable to the Beatles Sgt Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band. However, the enhanced version of Songs from the Big Chair, just gave the artist something to do to re-release a great great CD. My advise is to buy the original release and forget the trashed disco-ed. hip-hoped inventions of their MASTER PIECE- Songs From the Big Chair."