Great stuff
Anaximander | Texas | 01/19/2010
(4 out of 5 stars)
"This is essentially a Supergrass album with Gaz singing and Danny playing drums. When I initially heard about it, it sounded like an ill-conceived lark. Covers albums can be bland or just terrible. But it is actually quite good - maybe even better than the last official Supergrass album. They don't radically alter most of the covers on this album, but they make the songs their own. The playing is excellent, and Nigel Godrich's production is great. Sounds like they had a blast making it, too. One of the surprising highlights is "(You Gotta) Fight For Your Right (To Party)" - its really unrecongizable except for the lyrics. Their mostly accoustic version of "Damaged Goods" is fantastic. "Big Sky," a fairly obscure Kinks song, is great too. If you are still following Supergrass after all these years, you've got to pick this one up."
A must-have for any Supergrass fan-or any music fan, period!
Steve Wright | Bend, OR USA | 02/02/2010
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This is an outstanding piece by Gaz and Danny, not really indistinguishable from a proper Supergrass album other than the fact that these are covers. Their takes on various hits by other bands "Pump It Up", "I Can't Stand It", etc. often surpass the originals. I was a bit taken aback at the idea of Gaz covering Jim Morrison on "The Crystal Ship", but amazingly he pulls it off! Not a bad song in the batch. (and I HATE The Beastie Boys!)
If you love Supergrass, you'll love this. GET IT NOW."
If you like Pin-ups, you'll like this
Jeff Weiss | Muncie, IN | 02/24/2010
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I had really low expectations of this record but it is one of the best covers albums I have heard. It helps that all these songs (except the Beastie Boys) are among my faves. Even the tracks that don't quite make it (Love is the Drug, I Can't Stand It) develop rather nicely. Performing "(You gotta) Fight for Your Right to Party" like the Who ca. 1967 would do it is pretty genius. So is doing "Damaged Goods" acoustic. "Lovecats" holds up pretty well to being punked up as does the pop psych version of "Up the Junction". The tracks that stick too closely to the originals don't quite make it, but wasn't that the problem with Bowie's album too?"