Clare Quilty | a little pad in hawaii | 04/03/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Ordinarily, I prefer Monk in a trio setting. My favorite of his albums is "Thelonious Monk Plays Duke Ellington," in which it's just Monk's piano, drums and bass. That, to me, is just enough accompaniment to garnish his sound without crowding it.But oddly enough, I love the 1959 Town Hall Concert, in which Monk is part of a 10-piece band. I think it's something about the combination of Jay McAllister's tuba, Sam Jones' rubbery bass and the beautiful oddball baritone saxophone of Pepper Adams. This stuff swings ("Friday the 13th") and it's a fun album but also clearly a product of intense concentration on all sides. It's full of beautiful, melancholy moments ("Monk's Mood") but it also tweaks a Monk staple ("Crepsucule with Nellie"). And it just has some great, kick back and listen gems: a nicely bulked-up "Thelonious," and "Off Minor" and "Little Rootie Tootie" (both within the concert and as an encore). An excellent album."
MONK ON CENTER STAGE
Larry Brill | ny ny | 11/10/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"i was smart enough to be in the audience that nite. if you listen closely you can hear me applauding...and i still am! any album of monks' is worth the price of admission and this CD of LIVE big band monk is a one & only. there's mucho quartet, trio etc out there...i love the Black Lion solo stuff his wife made him do, all 6 CDs...and the LIVE 5 SPOT recordings (hear me clapping on those too?) BUY THIS...Buy EVERY monk side you can. he is a world treasure to be treasured over & over. ENJOY"
Monk stepping into yet "newer territory"
Manny Hernandez | Bay Area, CA | 09/15/2003
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Granted that the music in this album recorded in 1959 is not new in itself, the arrangements in it are different from your "typical" Thelonious Monk. He steps into big band-type territory, with the participation of a ten piece band, away from the 'more limited' standard four or five piece ensemble. To take the tracks into that new direction (consider there are parts for a tuba, Franch horn, trombone, trumpet, baritone, tenor and alto sax here, on top of the piano, bass and drums) he counted on Hall Overton, a long time Monk enthusiast and composer/pianist/teacher himself.Worth mentioning in particular are the opening track (I can keep on listening to it for a thousand times!) and the 9+ min long "Friday the 13th" where Phil Woods steps in with a quite remarkable alto sax solo."
The First Big Band
Richard W. Cutler | 04/10/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This concert from 1959 will inevitably be compared to the 1963 concert at Lincoln Center. Certainly, the latter was more expansive, including extended performances by Monk's quartet and even a piano solo, but this album has an exqusite charm, a freshness --perhaps because no one knew that Hall Overton could transpose Monk's music into such a graceful band setting. "Little Rootie Tootie" and "Thelonious" are stand-outs here --the latter even gets an orchestral underpinning like a stride piano-- but the unmistakable masterpiece is "Monk's Mood," which glistens under Eddie Bert's reading on trombone, with a lovely bridge by trumpeter Johnny Coles. (I think it was to Coles that Monk said "Don't play be-bop [expletive deleted] on my songs. You have to know the melody!") Charlie Rouse does not stretch out as long as on the 1963 concert recording, and I think the more compact result is a vast improvement."
Brontomonk
Nikica Gilic | 06/27/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Yes, this giant sized (brontosaurus) orchestra for Monk's usual standards (actually, quite a normal, even modest big-band sized orchestra) works really well. This CD should be owned by every Monk fan and modern jazz fan.
Should the die-hard big band fans tag along and acquire it?
It's hard to say: this is not a classical or even typical modernist big band - this is a logical extension of Monk's beautiful mind.
So, try for your self: I can personally never get too much Monk."